2013 -- H 5015 SUBSTITUTE B

=======

LC00144/SUB B/2

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2013

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO DOMESTIC RELATIONS - PERSONS ELIGIBLE TO MARRY

     Introduced By: Representatives Handy, Fox, Mattiello, Ferri, and Ruggiero

     Date Introduced: January 03, 2013

     Referred To: House Judiciary

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Sections 15-1-1, 15-1-2, 15-1-3, 15-1-4 and 15-1-5 of the General Laws in

1-2

Chapter 15-1 entitled "Persons Eligible to Marry" are hereby amended to read as follows:

1-3

     15-1-1. Men forbidden to marry kindred Equal access to marriage. -- No man shall

1-4

marry his mother, grandmother, daughter, son's daughter, daughter's daughter, stepmother,

1-5

grandfather's wife, son's wife, son's son's wife, daughter's son's wife, wife's mother, wife's

1-6

grandmother, wife's daughter, wife's son's daughter, wife's daughter's daughter, sister, brother's

1-7

daughter, sister's daughter, father's sister, or mother's sister. Any person who otherwise meets the

1-8

eligibility requirements of chapters 15-1 and 15-2 may marry any other eligible person regardless

1-9

of gender,

1-10

     15-1-2. Women forbidden to marry kindred Marrying kindred forbidden. -- No

1-11

woman shall marry her father, grandfather, son, son's son, daughter's son, stepfather,

1-12

grandmother's husband, daughter's husband, son's daughter's husband, daughter's daughter's

1-13

husband, husband's father, husband's grandfather, husband's son, husband's son's son, husband's

1-14

daughter's son, brother, brother's son, sister's son, father's brother, or mother's brother. No person

1-15

shall marry his or her sibling, parent, grandparent, child, grandchild, stepparent, grandparents'

1-16

spouse, spouse's child, spouse's grandchild, sibling's child or parent's sibling.

1-17

     15-1-3. Incestuous marriages void. -- If any man or woman person intermarries within

1-18

the degrees stated in section 15-1-1 or section 15-1-2, the marriage shall be null and void.

1-19

     15-1-4. Marriages of kindred allowed by Jewish religion. -- The provisions of sections

1-20

15-1-1 -- 15-1-3 15-1-2 and 15-1-3 shall not extend to, or in any way affect, any marriage which

2-1

shall be solemnized among the Jewish people, within the degrees of affinity or consanguinity

2-2

allowed by their religion.

2-3

     15-1-5. Bigamous marriages void -- Marriage of persons who are mentally

2-4

incompetent. – A person is prohibited from marrying if such person is:

2-5

     (1) A party to another marriage; or

2-6

     (2) A party to a relationship that provides substantially the same rights, benefits and

2-7

responsibilities as a marriage whether entered into in this state or another state or jurisdiction and

2-8

such marriage or relationship has not been finally dissolved, unless the parties to the intended

2-9

marriage will be the same as the parties to such other marriage or relationship. Any marriage

2-10

entered in violation of this prohibition when either of the parties at the time of the marriage has a

2-11

former wife or husband living who has not been, by final decree, divorced from that party, and

2-12

any marriage where either of the parties is mentally incompetent at the time of the marriage, shall

2-13

be absolutely void, and no life estate created by chapter 25 of title 33 shall be assigned to any

2-14

widow surviving spouse in consequence of the marriage.

2-15

     SECTION 2. Chapter 15-1 of the General Laws entitled "Persons Eligible to Marry" is

2-16

hereby amended by adding thereto the following sections:

2-17

     15-1-7. Marriage codification. – Marriage is the legally recognized union of two (2)

2-18

people. Terms relating to the marital relationship or familial relationships shall be construed

2-19

consistently with this section for all purposes throughout the law, whether in the context of

2-20

statute, administrative or court rule, policy, common law, or any other source of civil law.

2-21

     15-1-8. Recognition of relationships entered into in another state or jurisdiction. – lf

2-22

two (2) persons are within the jurisdiction of Rhode Island and have a legal union other than a

2-23

marriage that provides substantially the same rights, benefits and responsibilities as a marriage

2-24

and the union was validly entered into in another state or jurisdiction and the union is not

2-25

prohibited by this chapter then they shall be afforded the same rights, benefits and responsibilities

2-26

as a valid marriage in this state.

2-27

     15-1-9. Applicability of state laws to marriages not recognized by federal law. – (a)

2-28

Any provision of Rhode Island law that refers to, adopts, or relies upon provisions of federal law,

2-29

including, but not limited to, those in title 44, shall apply to parties recognized as married under

2-30

the laws of this state, as if federal laws recognized such marriages in the same manner as Rhode

2-31

Island law.

2-32

     (b) Notwithstanding the unavailability of federal financial participation, no person who is

2-33

recognized as a spouse under the laws of this state shall be denied benefits that are otherwise

2-34

available to spouses under Rhode Island law, including, but not limited to, those in chapters 40-8

3-1

to 40-8.10 inclusive, due to the provisions of 1 U.S.C. section 7 or any other federal non-

3-2

recognition of spouses of the same sex.

3-3

     SECTION 3. Sections 15-2-1, 15-2-7 and 15-2-11 of the General Laws in Chapter 15-2

3-4

entitled "Marriage Licenses" are hereby amended to read as follows:

3-5

     15-2-1. License required -- Proof of divorce License required -- Proof of divorce –

3-6

Obligation of clerk to issue license. -- (a) Persons intending to be joined together in marriage in

3-7

this state must first obtain a license from the clerk of the town or city in which:

3-8

      (1) The female Either party to the proposed marriage resides; or in the city or town in

3-9

which

3-10

      (2) The male party resides, if the female party is a nonresident of this state; or in the city

3-11

or town in which

3-12

     (3)(2) The proposed marriage is to be performed, if both parties are nonresidents of this

3-13

state.

3-14

      (b) Before any license shall be issued to any person who, having been previously married

3-15

or a party to another relationship that provides substantially the same rights, benefits and

3-16

responsibilities as a marriage, has been divorced, the person shall present to the town or city clerk

3-17

an authenticated copy of the decree granting the divorce or an authenticated copy of the final

3-18

dissolution of the previous relationship.

3-19

     (c) The town or city clerk shall issue a license to any person eligible to marry under the

3-20

provisions of chapter 15-1.

3-21

     15-2-7. Form and contents of certificates, reports, and other returns. -- The forms of

3-22

certificates, reports, and other returns required by this chapter, or by regulations adopted pursuant

3-23

to this chapter, shall include as a minimum the items recommended by the federal agency

3-24

responsible for national vital statistics, subject to approval of and modification by the state

3-25

director of health. Both the bride and groom parties shall subscribe to the truth of data in the

3-26

application in the presence of the local registrar or his or her assistant.

3-27

     15-2-11. Consent and procedure required for license to minors and persons under

3-28

guardianship. -- (a) No minor or person under the control of a parent or guardian shall be

3-29

allowed to give and subscribe to the information provided for in sections 15-2-1 -- 15-2-10, or

3-30

shall receive the license provided for in these sections, unless the consent in writing of the parent

3-31

or guardian, given in the presence of the town or city clerk or any clerk employed in that office,

3-32

has first been obtained; provided, that proof shall be submitted that the minor, if a female, has

3-33

attained the age of sixteen (16) years; and provided, that this information may be given and

3-34

subscribed to by a minor, if a female, who has attained the age of sixteen (16) years, residing in

4-1

this state upon the consent in writing of the director of public welfare of the town or city in which

4-2

the minor resides, given in the presence of the town or city clerk or any clerk employed in that

4-3

office.

4-4

      (b) In addition to the requirements in subsection (a) of this section, no license shall be

4-5

issued to any minor, if a female under the age of sixteen (16) years, and if a male under the age of

4-6

eighteen (18) years, unless and until the following requirements have been complied with, and the

4-7

town or city clerk is directed in writing to issue the license by the family court:

4-8

      (1) The town or city clerk, upon receiving information provided for in sections 15-2-1 --

4-9

through 15-2-10, shall immediately transmit a certified copy of the information to the family

4-10

court. The court shall immediately transmit a copy of the information, together with a written

4-11

request for a complete investigation of and a report upon the advisability of the issuance of the

4-12

license, to the department of human services. The department shall within fifteen (15) days after

4-13

the receipt of the information, the request, and the report file in the court its complete report in

4-14

writing.

4-15

      (2) The court shall then conduct a hearing in chambers to determine the advisability of

4-16

the issuance of the license and shall notify the town or city clerk of its determination. The court

4-17

shall have the power to summon at the hearing any persons that it may deem advisable.

4-18

      (3) The court shall also file the report and a notation of its determination in the office of

4-19

the clerk of the court, but any papers filed at the office of the clerk shall not be matters of public

4-20

record and may be examined only upon the written authorization of the court.

4-21

      (4) During the pendency of the proceedings, the court shall exercise the authority of a

4-22

guardian in respect to the minor or minors involved.

4-23

     SECTION 4. Chapter 15-3 of the General Laws entitled "Solemnization of Marriages" is

4-24

hereby amended by adding thereto the following section:

4-25

     15-3-6.1. Protection of freedom of religion in marriage. – (a) Consistent with the

4-26

guarantees of freedom of religion set forth by both the First Amendment to the United States

4-27

constitution and article I section 3 of the Rhode Island constitution, each religious institution has

4-28

exclusive control over its own religious doctrine, policy, and teachings regarding who may marry

4-29

within its faith, and on what terms, as long as such policies are consistent with sections 15-1-2,

4-30

15-1-3, 15-1-4 and 15-1-5. No court or other state or local governmental body, entity, agency or

4-31

commission shall compel, prevent, or interfere in any way with any religious institution's

4-32

decisions about marriage eligibility within that particular faith's tradition.

4-33

     (b) Consistent with the guarantees of freedom of religion set forth by both the First

4-34

Amendment to the United States Constitution and article I section 3 of the Rhode Island

5-1

constitution, no regularly licensed or ordained clergyperson, minister, elder, priest, imam, rabbi,

5-2

or similar official of any church or religious denomination as described and authorized in sections

5-3

15-3-5 and 15-3-6 of the general laws to officiate at a civil marriage, is required to solemnize any

5-4

marriage. A regularly licensed or ordained clergyperson, minister, elder, priest, imam, rabbi, or

5-5

similar official of any church or religious denomination shall be immune from any civil claim or

5-6

cause of action based on a refusal to solemnize any marriage under this chapter. No state agency

5-7

or local government may base a decision to penalize, withhold benefits from, or refuse to contract

5-8

with any church or religious denomination on the refusal of a person associated with such church

5-9

or religious denomination to solemnize a marriage under this chapter.

5-10

     (c) Notwithstanding any other provision of law, a religions organization, association, or

5-11

society, and any nonprofit institution or organization operated, supervised or controlled by a

5-12

religious organization, association or society, or a fraternal benefit or service organization that

5-13

has among its stated purposes the promotion and support or protection of a religious organization,

5-14

association or society and that restricts membership to practicing members of that religious

5-15

organization, association or society, shall not be required to provide services, accommodations,

5-16

advantages, facilities, goods, or privileges to an individual if the request for such services,

5-17

accommodations, advantages, facilities, goods, or privileges is related to:

5-18

     (1) The solemnization of a marriage or the celebration of a marriage, and such

5-19

solemnization or celebration is in violation of its religious beliefs and faith; or

5-20

     (2) The promotion of marriage through any social or religious programs or services,

5-21

which violates the religious doctrine or teachings of religious organization, association or society.

5-22

Any refusal by an entity described above or an officer, employee or member thereof acting in an

5-23

official capacity on behalf of that entity to provide services, accommodations, advantages,

5-24

facilities, goods, or privileges in accordance with this subsection shall not create any civil claim

5-25

or cause of action. This subsection shall not be construed to limit a religious organization,

5-26

association, or society, or a fraternal benefit or service organization as described in this

5-27

subsection, from selectively providing services, accommodations, advantages, facilities, goods, or

5-28

privileges to some individuals with respect to solemnization or celebration of a marriage but not

5-29

to others.

5-30

     (d) Nothing in the marriage laws of this state shall be deemed or construed to limit the

5-31

protections and exemptions provided to religious organizations under GL paragraph 28-5-6(7)(ii)

5-32

and subsection 34-37-4.2(a).

5-33

     (e) A fraternal benefit or service organization that is operated, supervised or controlled by

5-34

a religious organization and a fraternal benefit or service organization which has among its stated

6-1

purposes the promotion, support or protection of a religious organization and which restricts its

6-2

membership to practicing members of that religious organization shall not be required to admit

6-3

any individual as a member or to provide benefits to any individual. A refusal by a fraternal

6-4

benefit or service organization by a member, officer or employee thereof acting in an official

6-5

capacity on behalf of a society described herein, to admit an individual as a member or to provide

6-6

benefits related to a marriage which is in violation of the religious doctrine or teachings of the

6-7

religious organization to which its members are required to adhere, shall not create a civil claim

6-8

or result in any government action to penalize, withhold benefits from the fraternal benefit or

6-9

service organization or discriminate against a society or a member, officer or employee described

6-10

herein.

6-11

     SECTION 5. Chapter 15-3.1 of the General Laws entitled "Civil Unions" is hereby

6-12

amended by adding thereto the following sections:

6-13

     15-3.1-12. Merger of civil union into marriage by action of the parties. – (a) On and

6-14

after the effective date of this section, two (2) persons who are parties to a civil union entered into

6-15

pursuant to this chapter may apply for and be issued a marriage license and have such marriage

6-16

solemnized pursuant to chapters 15-1 to 15-3 of the general laws, provided such persons are

6-17

otherwise eligible to marry under chapter 15-1 as amended herein and the parties to the marriage

6-18

will be the same as the parties to the civil union. After the solemnization of such marriage, and

6-19

upon filing of the license and certificate of marriage with the clerk in the town or city from which

6-20

the license was issued pursuant to section 15-2-1, of the civil union of such persons shall be

6-21

merged into the marriage by operation of law as of the date of the recording of the marriage

6-22

certificate and shall be effective as of the date of the recording of the marriage certificate.

6-23

     (b) Such parties may also apply to the clerk of the town or city in which their civil union

6-24

is recorded to have their civil union legally designated and recorded as a marriage, without any

6-25

additional requirements of payment of marriage licensing fees or solemnization contained in

6-26

chapters 15-1 to 15-3 of the general laws, provided that such parties' civil union was not

6-27

previously dissolved or annulled. Upon application, the parties shall be issued a marriage

6-28

certificate and the civil union of such persons shall be merged into the marriage by operation of

6-29

law as of the date of the recording of the marriage certificate and shall be effective as of the date

6-30

of the recording of the marriage certificate.

6-31

     15-3.1-13. Recognized date of marriage. – For purposes of determining the legal rights

6-32

and responsibilities involving individuals who previously entered into a civil union in this state,

6-33

and whose civil union has merged into a marriage under this chapter, the date of the recording of

6-34

the marriage certificate shall be the operative date by which legal rights and responsibilities are

7-1

determined

7-2

     SECTION 6. Sections 15-3.1-3 and 15-3.1-4 of the General Laws in Chapter 15-3.1

7-3

entitled "Civil Unions" are hereby repealed.

7-4

     15-3.1-3. License requirements. -- (a) Persons intending to form a civil union in this

7-5

state must first obtain a license from the town or city in which:

7-6

      (1) One of the parties to the civil union resides; or

7-7

      (2) In the case of both parties being nonresidents of this state the city or town in which

7-8

the proposed civil union is to be performed.

7-9

      (b) Before any license shall be issued to any person who, having previously been married

7-10

or been a party in a civil union to someone other than their intended civil union partner, the

7-11

person shall present to the town or city clerk a certified copy of the decree granting the divorce or

7-12

dissolving the civil union.

7-13

      (c) The license required in: (a) shall be valid for three (3) months after the date of issue,

7-14

and if unused at the expiration of the three (3) months, the party or parties having the possession

7-15

of the license shall immediately return it to the town or city clerk from whom it was obtained.

7-16

      (d) License fee. - For issuing the civil union license the town or city clerk shall collect a

7-17

fee of twenty-four dollars ($24.00). The city or town shall retain eight dollars ($8.00), and

7-18

transmit sixteen dollars ($16.00) to the general treasurer of the State of Rhode Island who shall be

7-19

responsible for depositing eight dollars ($8.00) of the sixteen dollars ($16.00) received into the

7-20

family and children trust fund created by Rhode Island general laws section 42-72-30. Each clerk

7-21

shall keep an accurate account of all fees charged and received under this section and shall

7-22

transmit all sums due to the general treasurer at least monthly in the manner and with the forms

7-23

which the general treasurer shall prescribe.

7-24

      (e) The several town and city clerks shall record, in separate books to be kept by them

7-25

for that purpose, the information furnished to them and subscribed to as provided in this section.

7-26

Further, town and city clerks shall treat the civil union certificate as a vital record pursuant to

7-27

Rhode Island general laws chapter 23-3.

7-28

     15-3.1-4. Certification of civil unions. -- Officials empowered to certify persons in civil

7-29

unions:

7-30

      (1) Every ordained clergy or elder in good standing, every justice of the supreme court,

7-31

superior court, family court, workers' compensation court, district court or traffic tribunal, the

7-32

clerk of the supreme court, every clerk or general chief clerk of a superior court, family court,

7-33

district court, or traffic tribunal, magistrates, special or general magistrates of the superior court,

7-34

family court, traffic tribunal or district court, administrative clerks of the district court,

8-1

administrators of the workers' compensation court, every former justice or judge and former

8-2

administrator of these courts and every former chief clerk of the district court, and every former

8-3

clerk or general chief clerk of a superior court, the secretary of the senate, elected clerks of the

8-4

general assembly, any former secretary of the senate or any former elected clerk of the general

8-5

assembly who retires after July 1, 2007, judges of the United States appointed pursuant to Article

8-6

III of the United States Constitution, bankruptcy judges appointed pursuant to Article I of the

8-7

United States Constitution, and United States magistrate judges appointed pursuant to federal law,

8-8

may certify a civil union in any city or town in this state; and every justice and every former

8-9

justice of the municipal courts of the cities and towns in this state and of the police court of the

8-10

town of Johnston and every probate judge and every former probate judge may certify a civil

8-11

union in any city or town in this state, and wardens of the town of New Shoreham may certify

8-12

persons in civil unions in New Shoreham.

8-13

      (2) Every certification of a civil union shall be held in the presence of at least two (2)

8-14

witnesses besides the person officiating the certification and no minister, justice or other

8-15

authorized person shall perform the civil union certification until the persons to be certified in a

8-16

civil union have presented him or her the license named in this section.

8-17

      (3) Every minister, justice, or other authorized person who certifies any persons in a civil

8-18

union shall endorse the "License and Certificate of Civil Union" presented to him or her by the

8-19

persons and certify that the persons were certified in a civil union in accordance with the laws of

8-20

the State of Rhode Island and the person who certifies the parties in the civil union shall complete

8-21

all the information on the "License and Certificate of Civil Union" and file the form within

8-22

ninety- six (96) hours following the date of the civil union certification with the clerk in the town

8-23

or city from which the license was issued.

8-24

      (4) The town or city clerk to whom the civil union certificate is returned shall carefully

8-25

file and preserve the return.

8-26

      (5) If any person has any lawful objection to the civil union of any two (2) persons, he or

8-27

she may state the objection in writing, under his or her hand, to the minister, justice or other

8-28

authorized person about to certify the civil union, at which time the minister, justice or other

8-29

authorized person shall proceed no further in the civil union until the lawful objection has been

8-30

removed.

8-31

      (6) Every minister, justice, or other authorized person who certifies persons in a civil

8-32

union without first receiving the license required by this chapter containing the required

8-33

information, or whenever the certification of the civil union has been lawfully objected to and the

8-34

impediment is not removed, or when the person certifies parties in a civil union that he or she

9-1

knows to have a husband, wife, or other civil union partner shall be imprisoned not exceeding six

9-2

(6) months or fined not exceeding one thousand dollars ($1,000).

9-3

      (7) No civil union certified before a person professing to have a license or professing to

9-4

be qualified to certify the civil union shall be deemed or adjudged to be void, nor shall the

9-5

validity of the civil union be in any way affected by want of jurisdiction or authority in the person

9-6

by noncompliance with any of the requirements of this chapter, if the civil union is in other

9-7

respects lawful and has been certified with a full belief on the part of the parties to the civil union,

9-8

or either of them, that they have lawfully certified in a civil union.

9-9

      (8) Every person who certifies a civil union without being legally authorized to do so

9-10

shall be fined five hundred dollars ($500).

9-11

      (9) If, as the result of a court decision, any civil union which has occurred in Rhode

9-12

Island is declared invalid, the court shall order the state registrar of vital records to mark "invalid"

9-13

the original civil union record on file at the division of vital records and to note the invalidity of

9-14

the civil union on all other files or references to the civil union.

9-15

      (10) Whoever provides any false information as to the requirements under this chapter,

9-16

or whoever enters into a civil union without duly proceeding as is required by this chapter, shall

9-17

be fined not exceeding five hundred dollars ($500).

9-18

     SECTION 7. Severability.- If any provisions of the act or the application thereof to any

9-19

person or circumstances is held invalid, such invalidity shall not affect any other provisions or

9-20

applications of this act, which can be given effect without the invalid provision or application,

9-21

and to this end the provisions of this act are declared to be severable.

9-22

     SECTION 8. This act shall take effect on August 1, 2013.

=======

LC00144/SUB B/2

========

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO DOMESTIC RELATIONS - PERSONS ELIGIBLE TO MARRY

***

10-1

     This act would change terminology on marrying from gender based to non-gender based,

10-2

it would address prohibitions to marriage, redefine the term marriage, address other state and

10-3

federal law recognition and applicability in how the state of Rhode Island, address marriage

10-4

licenses in Rhode Island, protection of freedom of religion in marriages and the merger of civil

10-5

union into marriage.

10-6

     This act would take effect on August 1, 2013.

=======

LC00144/SUB B/2

=======