2022 -- H 7787 | |
======== | |
LC004842 | |
======== | |
STATE OF RHODE ISLAND | |
IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY | |
JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2022 | |
____________ | |
A N A C T | |
RELATING TO HEALTH AND SAFETY -- THE CLEAN ATMOSPHERE ACT | |
| |
Introduced By: Representatives Quattrocchi, Price, Nardone, Roberts, and Bennett | |
Date Introduced: March 03, 2022 | |
Referred To: House Environment and Natural Resources | |
It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows: | |
1 | SECTION 1. TITLE 23 of the General Laws entitled "HEALTH AND SAFETY" is hereby |
2 | amended by adding thereto the following chapter: |
3 | CHAPTER 23.8 |
4 | THE CLEAN ATMOSPHERE ACT |
5 | 23-23.8-1. Short title. |
6 | This chapter shall be known and may be cited as "The Clean Atmosphere Act". |
7 | 23-23.8-2. Legislative intent. |
8 | (a) It is the legislative intent to preserve the safe, peaceful use of Rhode Island's atmosphere |
9 | for people, the environment, and agriculture, and to expand upon climate efforts, by regulating |
10 | weather modification and other large-scale, atmospheric activities and prohibiting those which are |
11 | harmful. |
12 | (b) The general assembly finds that many atmospheric activities harm human health and |
13 | safety, the environment, agriculture, aviation, security, and the economy of the State of Rhode |
14 | Island. It is, therefore, the intention of this legislature to regulate hazardous atmospheric activities |
15 | as further set forth by the terms and provisions of this chapter. |
16 | 23-23.8-3. Findings of fact. |
17 | (a) Background: earthly life, or "bios", is a system that can be impaired and broken by |
18 | perturbations such as human activities that are xenobiotic, i.e., foreign to life. The extant damage |
19 | from pollutants and other harmful human activities is incalculable, and the state of earth's biotic |
| |
1 | system is widely reported as catastrophic and in urgent need of protective action. |
2 | (b) Scope: Inclusive of solar radiation management (SRM), carbon dioxide removal |
3 | (CDR), and other techniques, hazardous emissions activities are diverse, varying greatly in their |
4 | characteristics and consequences. Included herein are anthropogenic atmospheric activities, and |
5 | may involve ground-based, underwater, and atmosphere-based activities, including, without |
6 | limitation, aerosol injection, cloud-seeding and other deployments by facilities such as aircraft, |
7 | rockets, unmanned aerial vehicles (UAVs) and drones of all sizes down to large pico balloons, |
8 | wireless infrastructures, ships and submarines. |
9 | (c) Scope of regulatory authority: All atmospheric activities require state licensing. |
10 | (d) SRM activities include, without limitation, aerosol injection such as: |
11 | (1) Solar shields or atmospheric sunscreens where reflective materials are injected into the |
12 | stratosphere with the intention of increasing albedo. These include, without limitation, sulfur |
13 | dioxide (SO2), sulfuric acid (H2SO4) and aluminum oxide (Al2O3); |
14 | (i) SO2 and H2SO4: Sulphate releases produce toxic sulfate clouds. According to the |
15 | journal Geophysical Research Letters, SO2 injected into the atmosphere slowly converts to H2SO4 |
16 | to produce the adverse effects of ozone layer reduction and radiative forcing or heating of the lower |
17 | stratosphere through reflection and absorption of terrestrial heat. The U.S. Clean Air Act (42 |
18 | U.S.C. § 7401 et seq. (1970)) is focused on reducing SO2 and H2SO4, the primary components of |
19 | acid rain. According to the U.S. Environmental Protection Agency (EPA), SO2 penetrates deeply |
20 | into sensitive parts of the lungs, causing susceptibility to pathogens, and harms the environment. |
21 | (ii) Al2O3: According to the U.S. National Institutes of Health (NIH), Al2O3 causes |
22 | respiratory tract, eye, and skin irritation as well as organ damage and bone abnormalities, |
23 | particularly with repeated or prolonged exposure; and it may be neurotoxic if absorbed into the |
24 | brain. The U.S. Emergency Planning and Community Right-to-Know Act (EPCRA) § 313 requires |
25 | anyone manufacturing, processing, or using Al2O3 to report this activity to EPA. Any aircraft |
26 | containing a hazardous substance is considered by the U.S. Comprehensive Environmental |
27 | Response, Compensation, and Liability Act (CERCLA) § 103, and by EPCRA § 304, a "facility" |
28 | required to report any release into the environment. Whether users deploying substances into the |
29 | atmosphere do presently comply is unlikely. Typically, stratospheric releases of sulfuric and |
30 | aluminum oxide particulates fall into the troposphere, blocking sunlight from reaching earth's |
31 | surface, after which they rain down as acidic pollution, harming terrestrial and aquatic life. Acidic |
32 | precipitation further mobilizes aluminum from both natural sources and direct, anthropogenic |
33 | atmospheric releases and industrial processes. Acidification mobilizes aluminum from land into |
34 | aquatic environments and into human and animal brain tissues. Acid rain dissolves and washes |
| LC004842 - Page 2 of 24 |
1 | away the soil's nutrients and minerals, which help plants grow. It reduces photosynthesis by |
2 | removing the waxy cover on leaves and ultimately kills the aquatic life upon which human life |
3 | depends. |
4 | (2) Carbon black or black carbon releases: Deliberate, atmospheric releases of soot are used |
5 | to produce artificial weather events, increasing albedo and reflecting sunlight; in particular, |
6 | aerosolized coal combustion fly ash liberates dispersed aluminum, which, when absorbed into |
7 | human and other bodies, is a primary factor in the pronounced increase in neurological diseases |
8 | and the widespread debilitation of earth's biota; |
9 | (3) Rocket emissions: Entirely unregulated, these include, without limitation, black carbon |
10 | soot and alumina particles in addition to carbon monoxide (CO), chlorine, sulfuric compounds, |
11 | methane, and water vapor, a "greenhouse gas" blocking sunlight and reflecting terrestrial heat; |
12 | (4) Cloud brightening: Sodium chloride (NaCl) or sea salt, seawater, nitric acid (HNO3), |
13 | and other materials injected into clouds make the clouds more reflective, after which the salt and |
14 | other materials rain out over land areas and freshwater supplies – reinforcing the need for the 2021 |
15 | expansion of states' rights under the U.S. Clean Water Act. |
16 | (5) Salt flare rockets: Fired into clouds, salt flare rockets trigger rain downpours containing |
17 | salt, that contaminates freshwater supplies, desiccates surfaces, and makes the atmosphere and |
18 | exposed biota, including humans, more conductive; |
19 | (6) Cloud-seeding releases of Silver Iodide (AgI) and/or solid dry ice, which is carbon |
20 | dioxide (CO2), the latter increasing carbon levels that state policies rather intend to decrease; |
21 | (7) Cloud-cover production: Aerial releases of water vapor, a "greenhouse gas", result in |
22 | manmade cloud cover, trapping terrestrial heat; |
23 | (8) Reflective space mesh mirrors: Wire-mesh mirrors deployed in space reduce the |
24 | amount of direct sunlight reaching earth's surface over small or large areas, depending on their size; |
25 | (9) Space sunshades or sunshields: Huge, parasol-like devices reduce the amount of direct |
26 | sunlight reaching earth's surface; |
27 | (10) Planetary sunshades: These largest of SRM operations use particulates to cover, over |
28 | time, the whole earth, substantially stripping the ozone layer and reducing the amount of direct |
29 | sunlight reaching earth's surface; |
30 | (11) Artificial ionosphere: A sustained, high-density plasma cloud produced in earth's |
31 | upper atmosphere; |
32 | (12) Large helium balloons releasing atmospheric contaminants such as SO2; and |
33 | (13) Lithium releases. |
34 | (e) CDR, involving the sequestration, capture, and removal of carbon dioxide (CO2); |
| LC004842 - Page 3 of 24 |
1 | (1) Land-based and ocean-based carbon sequestration, also called CO2 geo-sequestration; |
2 | (2) Carbon capture or removal, involving the capture of what is considered "waste" CO2 |
3 | and its deposit at storage sites, in order to allow the oil industry to continue burning fossil fuels; |
4 | (3) Biochar, requiring burning huge amounts of biomass such as trees, crops, and solid |
5 | waste; |
6 | (4) Ocean fertilization (OF) by dumping iron filings, lime, and urea so as to sequester CO2, |
7 | producing detrimental artificial algae blooms and reducing oxygen and needed nutrients; and |
8 | (5) Genetically modified CO2-eating, plastic trees; |
9 | (f) Additional atmospheric activities requiring state licensing include, without limitation: |
10 | (1) Ocean-cooling pipes, which would rather exacerbate oceanic warming; |
11 | (2) Re-icing and/or cooling the Arctic and other areas through artificial means; |
12 | (3) Ground-based cloud-nucleating generators; |
13 | (4) Weather modification involving the release of sea salt, silver iodide, barium, and other |
14 | substances to enhance precipitation (rain or snow) in one area while reducing precipitation |
15 | elsewhere; |
16 | (5) Flame-throwing fire drones purposed to cause terrestrial fires, and certain other |
17 | controlled-burn methods; |
18 | (6) Glacier-reflecting blanket deployment, with vast polar areas to be covered with soot; |
19 | (7) Nitrogen removal and sequestration; |
20 | (8) Evaporation alteration, by spreading various kinds of film upon large bodies of water; |
21 | (9) Water vapor generation using nuclear fission or fusion, contaminating water sources; |
22 | (10) Chaff releases, which involve the dispersal of bundles of millions of aluminum-coated |
23 | glass fibers, often in lengths 1.5 centimeters (cm), 2.5cm, and 5cm, or nano-chaff that spread over |
24 | hundreds of miles, remain in the air for up to a day, or for years, and then fall and break apart; while |
25 | purposed to confuse foreign radars and satellite vision, chaff can causes power outages and interfere |
26 | with air-traffic control, weather forecasting and climate research; |
27 | (11) Deployment of radiofrequency/microwave (RF/MW) radiation, and low-frequency |
28 | electric or magnetic fields, other than those needed for safety and aviation communication by |
29 | infrastructures, individual and high-densification antennas at terrestrial surface and at higher |
30 | altitudes from satellites, and by other means or at other altitudes; and |
31 | (12) Intense mechanical vibration or noise other than from a facility's propulsion; and other |
32 | physical agents, such as intentional changes to ambient temperature or barometric pressure, or |
33 | excessive light at night, for any purpose, or inadvertently from other activities. |
34 | (g) Aircraft atmospheric activities include those carried out from or by any type of manned |
| LC004842 - Page 4 of 24 |
1 | or unmanned aerial vehicle (the latter "UAV"), rocket, drone, balloon, or other facility, which |
2 | involve the release or deployment of any nuclear radiation; any biologic or trans-biologic agent; |
3 | any chemical substance or mixture including any chemical substance added to the aircraft's fuel |
4 | emissions; cloud seeding; any electromagnetic radiation deployment other than radar or radio |
5 | communications necessary for the aircraft's safety; or any other harmful physical agent, shall be |
6 | subject to regulation including the licensing process, pursuant to this chapter. |
7 | (h) Consequences: Documented problems arising from hazardous atmospheric activities |
8 | include: |
9 | (1) Contamination of air, water, and soil, as particulates fall to earth's surface; and other |
10 | contaminants, including liquids, vapors and physical agents, impact the surface at or below ground |
11 | or sea level; |
12 | (2) Degradation of human, animal, insect, and plant health and productivity, with early |
13 | death, when people and other living organisms are exposed to released particulates, vapors and |
14 | other types of contaminants, often in violation of the U.S. National Environmental Policy Act of |
15 | 1970 (NEPA); |
16 | (3) The acceleration of biodiversity and species losses, especially the loss of endangered |
17 | and threatened species as identified under the U.S. Endangered Species Act of 1973 (ESA), each |
18 | of which species has intrinsic as well as human-resource and resiliency value, and each of which |
19 | cannot bear, per ESA, further habitat modification or degradation; |
20 | (4) Extreme weather, with unprecedented temperatures, fires, floods, wind speeds, |
21 | electrical storms, hurricanes and tornados, resulting in large-scale loss of life, damaged structures |
22 | and infrastructures; and severe reduction in state, regional, and global food production; with a |
23 | potential to breach state and national security; |
24 | (5) Changes in micro-climates, local weather, and large-scale climate areas within shorter |
25 | time periods, with increased and cascading climate effects and political ramifications; |
26 | (6) Global dimming, which decreases vitamin D (calciferol) in humans and animals, |
27 | causing malabsorption of calcium, magnesium and phosphate, with the increase of infections and |
28 | other diseases; and in plants, photosynthesis reduction, with losses in agricultural productivity; |
29 | (7) Less direct sunlight reaching earth's surface, with fewer winter freezes and higher |
30 | humidity, resulting in increased molds, mildews, fungi, and other pathogens and pests that develop |
31 | from such conditions – with human, animal and plant diseases resulting therefrom; |
32 | (8) Increases in acid rain loads from the airborne injection or releases of sulfur and |
33 | aluminum oxides, with human, animal, pollinating insect, plant, and water-resource degradation; |
34 | (9) Changes in distribution patterns and chemical contents of rainfall, resulting in floods, |
| LC004842 - Page 5 of 24 |
1 | droughts, and the potential for international political conflicts; |
2 | (10) Algal blooms, with impacts upon human health, aquatic systems, and economies; |
3 | (11) The near-impossibility of restoring devalued natural resources, with the undermining |
4 | and waste of state-funded conservation programs; |
5 | (12) The potential, through radiative forcing, to reflect too much heat back to earth, or to |
6 | produce excessive cold by reflecting too much cosmic energy away from earth, and to bring about |
7 | feedback loops by one or the other; |
8 | (13) Increased ultraviolet (UV) radiation (including UVA, UVB, and UVC) at earth's |
9 | surface: UV is strongly absorbed by organic materials such as living tissues, with UVC's high |
10 | energy and small wavelength particularly capable of destroying DNA and reproduction; |
11 | (14) Increased combustibility of earth's terrestrial surfaces, by means of fallen particulates, |
12 | some pyrophoric and/or desiccating, with increased fire incidence; |
13 | (15) Significant increases in ambient mechanical vibration and noise pollution, leading to, |
14 | without limitation, increased incidence of nervous system and cardiac irregularities; |
15 | (16) Increased metals content in surface-dwelling and aquatic organisms, producing |
16 | heightened bodily electrical conductivity and radiation absorption, with more susceptibilities and |
17 | damages; particularly where atmospheric electrical charges are naturally or otherwise intensified; |
18 | (17) Extreme harm to vulnerable human subpopulations and the more vulnerable species; |
19 | (18) Significant changes to earth's atmosphere's electric, magnetic, and electromagnetic |
20 | properties through the induction of high-intensity, decimeter, centimeter, and millimeter wave |
21 | microwave radiation from increasingly densified wireless facilities, terrestrial and atmospheric, |
22 | resulting in extreme and less predictable weather, the desiccation of humans, animals, insects and |
23 | plants; blood-cell clumping (Rouleaux formation), blood-clotting increase, and blood-oxygen |
24 | deprivation in humans and animals; diabetes and asthma increase in humans and animals; and the |
25 | reduction and ultimate eradication of animal and insect populations, particularly pollinators |
26 | dependent for navigation upon geomagnetism; |
27 | (19) Visibility impairment and clutter, reducing aviation safety and accelerating collision |
28 | rates with satellites, balloons and nearly one million "space-junk" or "space-debris" particles; |
29 | (20) RF/MW interference from the exponentially increasing number of microwave- |
30 | irradiating satellites with altimeters, global positioning system (GPS) and other international |
31 | position systems' signals, relied upon by the aviation industry in traffic separation, aircraft |
32 | navigation and instrument approaches for landing aircraft; and relied upon by militaries for national |
33 | security; with the need for more frequent replacement of equipment, potentially costing the public |
34 | billions of dollars; |
| LC004842 - Page 6 of 24 |
1 | (21) According to the William & Mary Law Review, the enabling of the Internet of Bodies |
2 | (IoB), a "mesh" or grid through which every human and most animals would contain worn, |
3 | ingested, inhaled, and injected chips or sensors of micro to pico size with transmitting antennas, |
4 | with every body functioning as an Internet node, toward complete warrantless surveillance and |
5 | control, even by foreign entities, with constant biometric data collection and loss of autonomy |
6 | under an over-arching artificial intelligence, in violation of the search and seizure laws set forth in |
7 | the Fourth Amendment of the U.S. Constitution and Rhode Island Constitution's Declaration of |
8 | Certain Constitutional Rights and Principles, Article I, Section 6; |
9 | (22) Vulnerability of communications signals including those for munitions from the |
10 | potential for solar flare alteration or demolition of space-based solar power systems; |
11 | (23) Electrical grid vulnerability to attack through the hackability of the so-called "smart" |
12 | grid and its "smart" devices; and the overconsumption of energy from densified microwave antenna |
13 | systems, as unsustainable; |
14 | (24) The sparking of fires, in addition to harm to health and the environment, from the |
15 | residential proximity of "smart" meters and their intense microwave radiation spikes; |
16 | (25) Increasing incidence of dementia, learning impairments, cardiovascular and |
17 | respiratory diseases, diabetes, autoimmune diseases, birth defects, infertility, cancers, and early |
18 | death in humans, and increasing impairment, disease, debility and early death likewise in other |
19 | living beings; |
20 | (26) Mass psychological and social changes by means of lithium and other psychoactive |
21 | substances' releases; |
22 | (27) The delay by decades of the ozone layer's potential recovery; |
23 | (28) Through carbon capture and sequestration programs, allowing oil-industry polluters |
24 | to continue burning fossil fuels, rather than stopping pollution before it exits the smokestack; |
25 | (29) The financial burden that airborne, reflective, metallic particulates such as chaff must |
26 | be repeatedly replenished by aircraft release, since their atmospheric time is limited; |
27 | (30) Further financial burden, since, according to the Pacific Northwest National |
28 | Laboratory, the amount of injected material is much less effective in polluted clouds, requiring the |
29 | injection of increasing amounts of chemical materials for cloud-brightening; |
30 | (31) Economic losses to various sectors of society and to the state itself, resulting from, |
31 | without limitation, human health damages, with productivity loss, increased and earlier health care |
32 | needs, and heightened suffering for those injured and sensitized by prior hazardous exposures; |
33 | contaminated soils and water supplies, loss of pollinators such as bees, butterflies and birds, de- |
34 | creased crop yields, dead and dying forests, loss of habitats, decline of fisheries, rising pollution |
| LC004842 - Page 7 of 24 |
1 | cleanup costs, and less solar power production from lack of sunlight reaching earth's surface; and |
2 | (32) The potential and ease for enemies, foreign and domestic, to cause harm intentionally. |
3 | (i) Necessity arising from federal stance: |
4 | (A) By shirking duties to protect national and state security, safety, human and |
5 | environmental health and property, the federal government has acted by various means to cause, |
6 | and permit harm through hazardous emission activities known to and in some cases funded by or |
7 | through U.S. agencies, thereby establishing, through the Tenth Amendment of the U.S. |
8 | Constitution, the authority and obligation of the states to override such destructive activities, acts |
9 | and policies, correct the federal government, cancel plans for hazardous activities involving |
10 | atmospheric contaminants such as, without limitation, those released in aerosol injection and by |
11 | high-densification antennas, and lawfully void contracts and permits pertaining thereto. |
12 | (B) Under the Ninth and Tenth Amendments of the U.S. Constitution and the Rhode Island |
13 | Constitution, no state lawmaker can act so as to deprive constituents of their health, safety, |
14 | environmental and agricultural health, their privacy, or their due, direct representation by their |
15 | public officials. States' rights, including their authorities, are correctly exerted where federal |
16 | restrictions have become oppressive or destructive; however, these rights can be used neither to |
17 | shrink state authorities under attempts of self-preemption from federal and otherwise granted |
18 | authorities, nor to obstruct authorities by appointees who block or disassemble them. A state law |
19 | attempting to nullify a portion of its own state constitution would result in the lawmaking body's |
20 | own nullification. As an existential constitutional threat, such misuse of the Tenth Amendment |
21 | does not authorize states to undermine the Ninth Amendment or any other federally granted rights |
22 | and authorities. Nor can the Tenth Amendment be abused to nullify any state constitutional |
23 | provisions such as the individual rights declared therein. Thus, no state or local government or |
24 | instrumentality thereof can lawfully act so as to self-preempt from its due protection of constituents, |
25 | and any such attempt, per Marbury vs. Madison, 5 US (2 Cranch) 137,174,176 (1803) as at once |
26 | self-nullifying and dissolving of that governmental body, shall be deemed void ab initio and |
27 | expressly terminated. |
28 | (C) In view of these facts, the general assembly declares that atmospheric activities must |
29 | be strictly regulated by the state through a licensing process with full enforcement capability, |
30 | through which an impact response conclusion (IRC) from the department of environmental |
31 | management (DEM), based on preliminary, detailed impact reports (IRs) from the state agencies, |
32 | state offices, departments, and programs included in § 23-23.8-5, as well as information gathered |
33 | in public hearings including public comment, must guide decision-making, pursuant to this chapter. |
34 | 23-23.8-4. Definitions. |
| LC004842 - Page 8 of 24 |
1 | As used in this chapter, the following words and phrases shall have the following meanings: |
2 | (1) "Albedo" means the fraction of incident radiation, such as light and heat, reflected by a |
3 | natural cloud or by materials injected into the atmosphere. |
4 | (2) "Announcement" means the publication on the publicly accessible Internet website of |
5 | the department of environmental management (DEM) a notification of the receipt of an application |
6 | from an entity or individual seeking to conduct or engage in an atmospheric activity. |
7 | (3) "Application" means a written request submitted by any entity or individual seeking to |
8 | implement, conduct or engage in any form of atmospheric activity, such as cloud-seeding. |
9 | (4) "Area" means a portion within the confines of the state or the state's territorial waters, |
10 | including the atmosphere above the state. |
11 | (5) "Atmospheric activity" means any human activity that occurs in the atmosphere and |
12 | may have harmful consequences upon health, the environment and agriculture. |
13 | (6) "Atmospheric contaminant" means any type of aerosol, chaff, biologic or transbiologic |
14 | agent, genetically modified agent, metal, radioactive material, vapor, particulate down to or less |
15 | than one nanometer in diameter, and any air pollutant regulated by the state, including without |
16 | limitation those deemed "unnecessary" pursuant to the general laws, xenobiotic (foreign-to-life) |
17 | electromagnetic radiation and fields, mechanical vibration and other physical agents, or any |
18 | combination of such contaminants. |
19 | (7) "Chaff" means aluminum-coated silica glass fibers typically dispersed in bundles |
20 | containing five million (5,000,000) to one hundred million (100,000,000) inhalable fibers, which |
21 | fall to the ground in about one day. |
22 | (8) "Conditions" means any limitations and safeguards to be placed on an applied-for |
23 | activity that is licensed by the director of the department of environmental management (DEM). |
24 | (9) "Department" or "DEM" means the state department of environmental management. |
25 | (10) "Director" means the director of the state department of environmental management. |
26 | (11) "Entity" means any of the following: individual; trust; firm; joint stock company; |
27 | corporation, including a quasi-governmental corporation; partnership; association; syndicate; |
28 | municipality or state or municipal agency; program; fire district; club; nonprofit agency; |
29 | commission; university or college in this state; department or agency of the state, the federal |
30 | government, or any interstate or international governance or instrumentality thereof, including |
31 | foreign, domestic and mercenary armed services; or region within the United States. |
32 | (12) "Geoengineering" means the intentional manipulation of the environment, involving |
33 | nuclear, biological, transbiological, chemical, electromagnetic and other physical-agent |
34 | contaminants that effect changes to earth's atmosphere or surface; and is inclusive of weather |
| LC004842 - Page 9 of 24 |
1 | modification. |
2 | (13) "Hazard" means a substance or physical agent by its nature harmful to living |
3 | organisms, generally, and to property or another interest of value. |
4 | (14) "Impact report" or "IR" means the report developed and submitted to the department |
5 | for publication, following the department's reception of an atmospheric activity application, by each |
6 | appropriate agency, office, department or program in this state, as identified herein, without |
7 | limitation, at § 23-23.8-5, assessing specific, actual and potential, short-term and long-term effects |
8 | upon human and environmental health and safety, aviation safety, agriculture, biodiversity, coastal |
9 | conservation, endangered species, energy consumption, fish and game, forestry, habitat, river and |
10 | ocean purity, water resources, wildlife, and the state's security and economy. |
11 | (15) "Impact Report Conclusion" or "IRC" means the department's collective conclusions |
12 | in response to the information-gathering process, based on substantive information in both the |
13 | impact reports (IRs) submitted by various state agencies and from members of the public. |
14 | (16) "Individual" means any man, woman or child. |
15 | (17) "License" means a contract, pursuant to this chapter, issued by the director of the DEM |
16 | to an applicant to engage in an atmospheric activity. |
17 | (18) "Long-term effects" means actual and potential consequences or impacts that may |
18 | manifest later than one year following the completion of an atmospheric activity. |
19 | (19) "Physical agent" means an agent other than a substance, including, without limitation, |
20 | radiofrequency/microwave (RF/MW) and other electromagnetic radiation and fields, barometric |
21 | pressure, temperature, gravity, kinetic weaponry, mechanical vibration and sound. |
22 | (20) "Post-activity report" or "PAR" means the report that must be submitted by the |
23 | licensee to the department of environmental management following the completion of a licensed |
24 | activity. |
25 | (21) "Radiative forcing" means measures of heat energy coming from the sun and reflected |
26 | back to space, versus measures of terrestrial heat energy, reflected back to earth's surface. |
27 | (22) "Release" means any activity that results in the issuance of contaminants such as the |
28 | emitting, transmitting, discharging or injecting of one or more nuclear, biological, transbiological, |
29 | chemical, or physical agents into the ambient atmosphere; whether once, intermittently, or |
30 | continuously. |
31 | (23) "Short-term effects" means actual and potential consequences or impacts that may |
32 | manifest within one year of the completion of an atmospheric activity. |
33 | (24) "Stratosphere" means the region of the upper atmosphere extending upward from the |
34 | edge of the troposphere to about thirty (30) miles above the earth. |
| LC004842 - Page 10 of 24 |
1 | (25) "Troposphere" means the region of the lowest layer of the atmosphere, six (6) to |
2 | twelve (12) miles high in altitude, wherein temperature steadily drops with increasing altitude and |
3 | nearly all cloud formations occur and weather conditions manifest. |
4 | (26) "Weather modification" means changing, controlling, or interfering with; or |
5 | attempting to change, control, or interfere with; the natural development of cloud forms, |
6 | precipitation, barometric pressure, temperature, conductivity and/or other electromagnetic or sonic |
7 | characteristics of the atmosphere. |
8 | (27) "Website" means the department's publicly accessible Internet website. |
9 | 23-23.8--5. Regulation by the state. |
10 | (a) This chapter, being necessary for the welfare of the state and its inhabitants and its |
11 | officials' obligation to promote the safety of life and property, and due to the potential for significant |
12 | harm, the following shall apply: |
13 | (1) All state climate-related appointees must be, or have been, administered the state oath |
14 | of office and must fulfill the obligations thereunder to protect the state and federal constitutions |
15 | and Rhode Island constituents, requiring appointees' direct responsiveness to constituents and not |
16 | to foreign or out-of-state entities; and |
17 | (2) Any contemplated atmospheric activity in or above the State of Rhode Island requires |
18 | the submission of a written application to request a license to engage in a specific type of activity |
19 | to begin on a specified date during a period of time not to exceed five (5) days. |
20 | (b) A license shall be issued pursuant to the following process: |
21 | (1) The department shall carry out an extensive public evaluation of any atmospheric |
22 | activity application, as specified herein. |
23 | (2) Following the evaluation process, the director shall have the power to: |
24 | (i) Grant or deny a license; |
25 | (ii) Modify the conditions of a license; and |
26 | (iii) Revoke a license for cause. |
27 | (3) The director shall issue publicly a decision to grant, deny, or conditionally grant, a |
28 | license. |
29 | (c) To obtain a license under this section, an applicant must have shown proof of |
30 | environmental health and safety and that the applied-for activity will produce zero hazardous |
31 | emissions, noting exemptions specified herein. If a license is granted, it is drafted as a contract only |
32 | between the department and the licensee, and may be modified after an additional brief evaluation |
33 | process, or revoked for cause. |
34 | (d) The department shall refer potential violations as reported by state agencies or members |
| LC004842 - Page 11 of 24 |
1 | of the public, to the DEM office of compliance and inspection (OC&I) office, as detailed herein. |
2 | (e) There is hereby created a health-and-environment protection trust fund in the state |
3 | treasury into which shall be deposited application fees and violation fines under this chapter. |
4 | (f) The director shall allocate funds in the health and environment protection fund to |
5 | counties in support of Rhode Island state residents' environmental and agricultural health. The |
6 | funds shall not be used by employees of the department. |
7 | (g) Monies from the trust fund shall be used, for example: |
8 | (1) To promote healthy food resilience by supporting local, organic-permaculture, small- |
9 | scale and home "victory gardens"; |
10 | (2) To improve ground-water quality by educating the public about the disadvantages of |
11 | home and business use of toxic maintenance and cosmetic substances; |
12 | (3) To reduce auto emissions by relaxing standards for residential-area small businesses, |
13 | allowing for more local shopping and alternative transport thereto; |
14 | (4) To reduce energy consumption by requiring wired communications such as analog or |
15 | other wired utility meters and fiber-optics to the premises (FTTP), by enacting a curfew of office |
16 | lights, wifi and beam-forming radiation out after the hour of eleven o'clock (11:00) p.m. by |
17 | requiring geothermal and passive solar in new construction, and by allowing and supporting off- |
18 | grid self-sufficiency and solar direct-to-device. |
19 | (5) To set up "free zones" where people and animals alike can reside and recreate, free |
20 | from polluting chemicals, RF/MW radiation and other hazards; and |
21 | (6) To produce accurate, comprehensive curricula about hazardous emissions and their |
22 | remedies, and to introduce these in university-level and grades kindergarten through twelve (K-12) |
23 | study. |
24 | (h) Any municipality that fails to use its allocated money for productive environmental and |
25 | agricultural health projects may have its funds withheld in the subsequent year. |
26 | (i) The department is authorized to, and shall, promulgate regulations to implement this |
27 | chapter, including, without limitation: |
28 | (1) Placing submitted applications, evaluative materials, decisions, and licensing upon the |
29 | website; |
30 | (2) Soliciting and obtaining impact reports (IRs), holding hearings and providing a |
31 | comment period, composing and revising the impact report conclusion (IRC), and evaluating an |
32 | applicant's written application response (AR) and a licensee's post-activity report (PAR) in response |
33 | to the evaluative processes detailed in this section; |
34 | (3) Granting or denying licensing in response to applications submitted under this section, |
| LC004842 - Page 12 of 24 |
1 | which applications shall be decided on a case-by-case basis; |
2 | (4) Determining when violations have occurred and referring them to compliance |
3 | authorities; and |
4 | (5) Allocating to each municipality the funds in the health-and-environment protection |
5 | fund. |
6 | 23-23.8-6. License applications. |
7 | (a) The department shall promulgate a written application to conduct atmospheric activities |
8 | in Rhode Island. An entity seeking to implement, conduct or engage in any form of atmospheric |
9 | activity within or above any area of the state shall submit to the director the application for a license, |
10 | in both hardcopy and electronic forms, along with the proposed GPS and altitude locations for the |
11 | activity, start and end dates encompassing less than or equal to five (5) days, and a fee of one |
12 | thousand dollars ($1,000). |
13 | (b) The application process requires the following information as well as other information, |
14 | as promulgated by the director: |
15 | (1) A detailed description of the contemplated activity, including the purposes, scope, |
16 | methods, materials, equipment, devices, physical agents and timing of activity of less than or equal |
17 | to five (5) days; |
18 | (2) The following: |
19 | (i) Sources, sizes, amounts and concentrations of all materials and the precise chemical |
20 | formulas of any substance or mixture to be used in the activity; |
21 | (ii) The resulting products during and following deployment of a substance or mixture |
22 | listed under subsection (b)(2)(i). |
23 | (iii) The biological and/or transbiological materials used in the activity, along with any |
24 | potential interactions of the materials and physical agents such as electromagnetism during and |
25 | following deployment; and |
26 | (iv) The source equipment, such as tanks, hoses, dispersal jets, and ionizers; and generating |
27 | equipment for various frequencies, modulation characteristics and rates, intensities and |
28 | concentrations, directionalities, reflection and duration specifications of any type of |
29 | electromagnetism or other physical agent to be deployed or potentially released, intentionally or |
30 | inadvertently, during the activity. |
31 | (3) Proof of safety to life and property, including human and environmental health, during |
32 | and following the activity, with substantiating evidentiary documents from independent sources. |
33 | (4) The names, educational and professional backgrounds and qualifications of all |
34 | individuals to be involved in the activity, along with all prior employment and business ownerships. |
| LC004842 - Page 13 of 24 |
1 | (5) A criminal background check of each participant in a potential atmospheric activity. |
2 | (6) The name and number of any aircraft or other vehicle or facility that may be used for |
3 | the activity. |
4 | (7) A one thousand dollar ($1,000) fee, or a five hundred dollar ($500) fee only for farmers |
5 | who apply to carry out crop-dusting, to be paid into a public trust, which shall be set up by the |
6 | director for the purpose of this act. |
7 | (8) A signed hardcopy application and an electronic copy of the application. |
8 | (c) The director shall acknowledge receipt of the application to the applicant within one |
9 | business day of receipt, and the same day shall place the application on the website, with signatures |
10 | redacted, and shall notify the following and others who may express interest in receiving notice: |
11 | (1) Rhode Island department of health; |
12 | (2) Disability Rights Rhode Island (DRRI); |
13 | (3) Division of agriculture within the DEM; |
14 | (4) Office of air resources within the DEM; |
15 | (5) Office of water resources within the DEM; |
16 | (6) Rhode Island marine fisheries council within DEM; |
17 | (7) Division of fish and wildlife outdoor education within DEM; |
18 | (8) Rhode Island parks & recreation within DEM; |
19 | (9) Rhode Island coastal resources management council; |
20 | (10) Rhode Island water resources board; |
21 | (11) Rhode Island office of energy resources; |
22 | (12) University of Rhode Island coastal institute; |
23 | (13) Rhode Island state conservation committee; |
24 | (14) Rhode Island airport corporation; |
25 | (15) Clean Water Action – Rhode Island; |
26 | (16) Rhode Island fishermen's alliance; |
27 | (17) Rhode Island farm bureau; |
28 | (18) Rhode Island dairy farms cooperative; |
29 | (19) Rhode Island Audubon society; |
30 | (20) Rhode Island beekeepers association; |
31 | (21) Rhode Island wild plant society: |
32 | (22) Land conservancy of North Kingstown; and |
33 | (23) Rhode Islanders for safe technology. |
34 | (d) The director is further authorized to, and should, subpoena witnesses, administer oaths, |
| LC004842 - Page 14 of 24 |
1 | and compel the production of documents for the hearing process. |
2 | 23-23.8-7. Application evaluation. |
3 | (a) An applied-for activity must first be evaluated by the department and the applicable |
4 | agencies, offices, departments and programs in this state, which shall produce, under the instruction |
5 | of the director, their respective impact reports (IRs) in their respective subject areas: |
6 | (1) The planned methods of release, dispersal, or other deployment of substances or |
7 | physical agents into the environment including the atmosphere; |
8 | (2) The potential impact in the reduction of or increase in sunlight reaching earth's surface; |
9 | (3) The anticipated radiative forcing or heat, if any, reflected to earth's surface and to space; |
10 | (4) The potential and actual, direct and indirect effects upon humans and other living |
11 | organisms, populations, ecosystems, agriculture, astronomy, aviation, property, and the state's |
12 | security and economy; |
13 | (5) Transboundary effects; |
14 | (6) The short- and long-term effects of each of the above; and |
15 | (7) The start and end date conflicts, if any, within the state. |
16 | (b) Each IR shall include a recommendation to allow, disallow, or to allow in a qualified |
17 | way with conditions, the applied-for activity. |
18 | (c) Within three (3) weeks of application submission, or other standardized period as |
19 | promulgated by the director, the department shall publish on the website all IRs, citing all actual |
20 | and potential impacts of the applied-for activity, both short-term and long-term, defined |
21 | respectively as within and beyond one year from completion of the activity. |
22 | (d) The department shall at once publish on its website dates of two (2) public hearings |
23 | with a comment period on the applied-for activity, noting in said publication the importance of |
24 | potential contributors' provisions of substantive information – of facts and laws – with supportive |
25 | written evidence. |
26 | (e) The department shall seek public comment and testimony for any applied-for activity |
27 | for which an applicant has submitted an application under this section. Invited testimony shall |
28 | include, without limitation, comments of the following individuals and their communities, as |
29 | locatable through advocacy organizations and more: |
30 | (1) Individuals with disabilities and those with health conditions that may be affected by |
31 | atmospheric contaminants; |
32 | (2) Medical and public health science professionals; |
33 | (3) Other experts including, without limitation, health and environmental science, |
34 | agriculture, astronomy, aviation, beekeeping, coastal integrity, conservation, disability, ecology, |
| LC004842 - Page 15 of 24 |
1 | economy, fish and game, foraging, forestry, ornithology, permaculture, toxicology, wildlife; and |
2 | water purity in lakes, rivers, wetlands and the ocean; |
3 | (4) Legal experts in warrantless surveillance and privacy rights, rights to public safety and |
4 | freedom from imposed medical protocols, both intentional and effectively functioning as such; |
5 | (5) Weaponry experts in nuclear, biological, chemical, electromagnetic, sonic, and others; |
6 | and experts in security therefrom; and |
7 | (6) Other interested individuals and organizations in Rhode Island that might ask the |
8 | department to provide notice when receiving license applications. |
9 | (f) The department shall hold two (2) hearings separated by a period of two (2) weeks and |
10 | over a total comment period of five (5) weeks from the first hearing, or longer periods, as shall be |
11 | promulgated by the director for the purpose of collecting further substantive information. |
12 | (g) Following the close of the comment period, in response to the above hearings and |
13 | received information, the department shall within three (3) weeks or a reasonable period to be |
14 | promulgated by the director, draft its IRC summarizing the content collected in the above IRs and |
15 | public processes, citing the collected safety, environmental health, agricultural, coastal, economic, |
16 | security, and other impacts of the applied-for activity, tentatively recommending the granting or |
17 | denying of the license, and publish the IRC on the website. |
18 | (h) The director shall supplement the IRC by adding any new, pertinent information |
19 | received by the department, and shall correct any misinformation and make precise any vague |
20 | statement in the draft IRC. |
21 | (i) Within ten (10) days, the department shall complete the revision of the draft IRC and |
22 | publish its final IRC with recommendation to grant, deny, or grant in a qualified way, the applied- |
23 | for activity. |
24 | (j) The applicant then shall have ten (10) days to respond to the final IRC, to substantiate |
25 | comprehensively any disagreement with the IRC, IR, and public comments and to prove health and |
26 | safety in a written application response (AR). Within one business day of receipt, the department |
27 | shall publish the AR on its website. |
28 | 23-23.8-8. Decision-making criteria -- Application of federal law. |
29 | (a) Within ten (10) days or a reasonable period to be promulgated by the director, the |
30 | director shall announce on the website the final decision whether to grant, deny, or grant with stated |
31 | conditions, the applied-for license. |
32 | (b) The department shall weight in the IRC bodily security, health, and environmental and |
33 | agricultural protection more heavily than economic interests. |
34 | (c) The department shall include in the IRC prepared under this subsection the factual and |
| LC004842 - Page 16 of 24 |
1 | legal information presented at any pertinent hearings held by the department, recognizing, without |
2 | limitation, the Ninth Amendment protection of individual rights to privacy and freedom from |
3 | assault in one's home and body, as superseding both any federal impositions and Tenth Amendment |
4 | states' rights. |
5 | (d) Since, under the Universal Declaration of Human Rights, adopted by the United |
6 | Nations General Assembly to which the United States is a signatory, "Everyone has the right to |
7 | life, liberty and security of person," (Article 3), those harmed or more likely to be harmed bodily |
8 | by way of atmospheric activities have a greater right than do stakeholders with monetary interests, |
9 | and this bodily right shall be weighted by the department more heavily than financial interest in |
10 | licensing and appeals decisions. |
11 | (e) Further, the federal Americans with Disabilities Act provides that persons with |
12 | disabilities be able to participate in society without being harmed. |
13 | (f) The federal Fair Housing Amendment Act allows persons with disabilities dwellings |
14 | that are accessible, i.e., free of harm, including from exogenous circumstances such as potentially |
15 | hazardous activities. |
16 | (g) COVID precedents have established that human health is to be prioritized above |
17 | financial interests. |
18 | (h) Since atmospheric activities carried out even at extremely high altitudes may result in |
19 | serious terrestrial consequences in communities and even within homes and bodies, persons with |
20 | disabilities who are more susceptible to harm by way of prior injuries, exposures, impairments, |
21 | illnesses, or other reasons, have weightier stakeholder status under this section. |
22 | 23-23.8-9. Application denial -- Criteria. |
23 | The department shall deny an application if either of the following is true: |
24 | (1) An applicable impact report (IR) substantively recommends that the applied-for activity |
25 | be disallowed; or |
26 | (2) An applicant has not disproven the validity of evidence submitted under this chapter |
27 | that the applied-for activity is harmful. |
28 | 23-23.8-10. Granting of license -- License agreement. |
29 | (a) If licensing the activity, the director shall, within ten (10) days or a reasonable period |
30 | to be promulgated, draft a license agreement. |
31 | (b) Upon granting a license under this chapter, the director shall first issue the applicant a |
32 | draft agreement potentially to be executed, which shall include: |
33 | (1) A detailed list of the department's conditions, limitations, and safeguards placed upon |
34 | the activity; |
| LC004842 - Page 17 of 24 |
1 | (2) Steps to be taken to document each aspect of the activity by the hour and minute with |
2 | GPS location and altitude, and to track observable effects of the activity in real time; and |
3 | (3) Follow-up requirements for the detailed PAR to be submitted to the department by the |
4 | licensee within thirty (30) days after completion of the activity. / |
5 | (c) Where a license is to be granted, the potential licensee must provide proof of insurance |
6 | and bonding for the specific activity at least three (3) weeks prior to the activity start date, or else |
7 | the license is void, in which case the director shall immediately provide notice to the applicant of |
8 | void status, and place such notice on the website. |
9 | 23-23.8-11. Application fee. |
10 | The director shall ensure that the applicant's fee is deposited within the health-and- |
11 | environment protection fund. |
12 | 23-23.8-12. Execution of agreement. |
13 | (a) The applicant must provide: |
14 | (1) A signed hardcopy and electronic copy of the agreement with the signatory's indication |
15 | of all participants' understandings of the potential for adverse consequences if the terms and |
16 | conditions are violated or not fulfilled; |
17 | (2) An agreement to document the hour, minute, and GPS location or locations and altitude |
18 | or altitudes of each aspect of the activity or activities; and |
19 | (3) An agreement to submit a PAR within thirty (30) days of completion of the activity, to |
20 | ensure that each aspect of the activity was carried out as agreed. |
21 | (b) The director shall execute the agreement and issue the license to the applicant pursuant |
22 | to § 23-23.8-10, if the director finds the applicant's signature, bonding, insurance, and other |
23 | requirements to be complete and accurate. |
24 | (c) In the case of a denial pursuant to § 23-23.8-10, the director shall provide the applicant |
25 | summary reasons for denial, as substantiated within the IRC. |
26 | 23-23.8-13. License status -- Limitations. |
27 | (a) A license is a contract between the department and the licensee only, and is also a public |
28 | document from which signatures may be redacted prior to publication on the department's website. |
29 | (b) A license must not be used for any activity other than that specified in the license. |
30 | 23-23.8-14. Confirmation of atmospheric activity -- Public notice. |
31 | (a) A licensee must confirm in writing to the department at least two (2) weeks in advance |
32 | of the start date of its intent to carry out the activity on the licensed start date pursuant to the terms |
33 | of the license agreement. |
34 | (b) Should the applicant wish to delay the start date of the applied-for activity, such request |
| LC004842 - Page 18 of 24 |
1 | and reasons for proposed modification must be submitted to the department in a timely manner, |
2 | and shall be deliberated publicly during an additional ten (10) day period to ensure that the new, |
3 | proposed date or dates do not conflict with state or other activities. |
4 | (c) After the additional ten (10) day deliberation period set forth in subsection (b), the |
5 | director shall issue a decision to modify or not modify the license's start date. |
6 | (d) The department shall notify the public on its website of the activity's commencement |
7 | seven (7) days in advance of the start date. |
8 | 23-23.8-15. Live data collection -- Post-activity report. |
9 | (a) The department shall collect during and after an activity any and all reports from the |
10 | public and other sources, along with its OC&I, as detailed in this chapter. |
11 | (b) A detailed PAR with a signature and an electronic copy must be submitted to the |
12 | department by a licensee within thirty (30) days after completion of the activity, including the steps |
13 | taken to ensure safety and track effects, the hour, minute, GPS location and altitude of each aspect |
14 | of the activity, and any effects observed to-date. |
15 | 23-23.8-16. Post-activity public hearing. |
16 | Within forty (40) days of the completion of an activity licensed pursuant to this chapter, |
17 | the director shall publish the PAR, any other collected public information and reports, and other |
18 | reports on the website, and shall convene a public hearing to occur within sixty (60) days of the |
19 | completion of the activity to discuss the effects of the activity. |
20 | 23-23.8-17. Appeals. |
21 | An applicant aggrieved by a decision of the director pursuant to this chapter may seek |
22 | judicial review of the decision pursuant to chapter 35 of title 42 (administrative procedure act). |
23 | 23-23.8-18. Unlicensed activity. |
24 | (a) The director shall immediately issue a cease-and-desist order upon the discovery of an |
25 | unlicensed atmospheric activity, where an agency, department, office, program, or member of the |
26 | public produces evidence to the department that the activity may be harmful or involves a |
27 | hazardous emission; and |
28 | (b) The cease-and-desist order under subsection (a) of this section shall have the weight of |
29 | a court order and any violation shall be punished under law. |
30 | 23-23.8-19. Departmental notice to cease federal or internationally-approved |
31 | programs. |
32 | (a) Where an activity that the department has deemed hazardous has been approved, |
33 | explicitly or implicitly, by the federal government, the department shall issue a notice to the |
34 | appropriate federal authority and/or the Federal Aviation Administration (FAA) that the hazardous |
| LC004842 - Page 19 of 24 |
1 | activity cannot lawfully be carried out within or over the State of Rhode Island, pursuant to the |
2 | Tenth Amendment of the United States Constitution. |
3 | (b) A foreign state or international body that funds in-part or in-whole or engages in an |
4 | activity deemed hazardous by the department shall be prohibited in perpetuity from both engaging |
5 | in and applying to engage in atmospheric activities in or above the State of Rhode Island. The |
6 | department is authorized to provide notice to such foreign state or international body that the |
7 | hazardous activity cannot lawfully be carried out within or over the State of Rhode Island. |
8 | 23-23.8-20. Penalties and Enforcement. |
9 | An unlicensed entity or individual that engages in an activity requiring a license under this |
10 | chapter or who fails to comply with the decision of the director, or any entity or person who uses |
11 | an unmarked or unidentified aircraft or other vehicle or facility to carry out an atmospheric activity: |
12 | (1) Has committed a felony and shall pay a fine of not less than five hundred thousand |
13 | dollars ($500,000) or be imprisoned for not less than two (2) years, or both; |
14 | (2) Shall be guilty of a separate offense for each day during which violative activity has |
15 | been conducted, repeated, or continued; and |
16 | (3) Shall also be deemed in violation and subject to further penalties under § 23-23-14. |
17 | 23-23.8-21. Public participation -- Reporting. |
18 | (a) The department shall post advertisements in newspapers of general circulation and on |
19 | the website to encourage the public to monitor, measure, document and report present, potential |
20 | and past incidents that may constitute harmful atmospheric activity. |
21 | (b) An individual who presents evidence of potentially harmful atmospheric activity under |
22 | subsection (a) of this section shall email or otherwise write and send any of the following to the |
23 | director or to any state police office or public official: |
24 | (1) Evidentiary photographs, each separately titled as an electronic or hardcopy document, |
25 | with the respective location from which, and, if the content is from other than a measuring device, |
26 | the direction in which, the photo was taken, with its time and date; |
27 | (2) Collected samples with photography, videography, audiography, lab tests, microscopy, |
28 | spectrometry, metering, and other forms of evidence shall similarly be submitted in writing to the |
29 | director or to any state office, or any state public official; and |
30 | (3) Videography of activity involving hazardous emissions. |
31 | (c) A public official who has received information under subsection (a) of this section and |
32 | has reason to suspect violative activity based on evidence presented by an agency or individual |
33 | under subsection (b) of this section must, directly or through a designee, report in writing within |
34 | hours, all documentary and supportive evidence to the DEM OC&I for enforcement. |
| LC004842 - Page 20 of 24 |
1 | (d) A report to any state official of apparently harmful nuclear, biological, transbiological |
2 | and/or chemical ("NBC") emissions shall trigger investigation of the source and contents of said |
3 | emissions, potentially through FAA, without limitation. Spectrometry of air and rainwater and other |
4 | testing may be used to determine specific contents of emissions. Where the emissions are harmful |
5 | to humans or the environment, per primary scientific study, enforcement shall ensue pursuant to § |
6 | 23-23.8-19. |
7 | (e) A report to any state official of excessive electromagnetic radiation or fields in any part |
8 | of the spectrum, including without limitation microwave or maser, infrared, light or laser, and |
9 | ionizing radiation, or report of intense mechanical vibration, noise, or other physical agent, with |
10 | evidence, including possible photographs, videography, audio recordings, measurements of the |
11 | agents, or other detection, shall trigger immediately for attention within two (2) hours OC&I |
12 | emergency measurements of peaks and averages over time with the appropriate, calibrated meters |
13 | and forensic, detection devices both at and near the reported location. Where professional metering |
14 | and monitoring equipment is needed but not owned by the state, OC&I personnel shall partner with |
15 | academic institutions for investigative activity, so as to provide evidentiary findings that would |
16 | qualify under the U.S. Supreme Court Daubert Rule ( Daubert v. Merrell Dow Pharmaceuticals |
17 | Inc., 509 U.S. 579). |
18 | 23-23.8-22. Investigatory findings -- Responses. |
19 | A finding of: |
20 | (1) Any NBCs that are either xenobiotic and should not exist in the natural environment, |
21 | or that are found at xenobiotic levels or levels beyond the legal limits of the state or federal |
22 | government, shall trigger enforcement as follows, over all federal, state and corporate entities: |
23 | (i) OC&I's immediate communication of the requirement of the owner and operator of each |
24 | facility or infrastructure deploying or releasing the specific agents, to produce records of all data |
25 | collection on emissions of the extant operations of any site at or near where xenobiotic agents or |
26 | excessive levels are or have been detected, and convey said records to the department; |
27 | (ii) OC&I's order to cease operations of the facilities or infrastructures other than those |
28 | operations needed for police, fire, emergency services, and aviation safety; and |
29 | (iii) OC&I's evaluation within twenty-four (24) hours of the owner's or operator's |
30 | performance in causing the cessation of all operations except those activities exempted under |
31 | subsection (ii) of this section. |
32 | (2) Radiofrequency/microwave (RF/MW) radiation, including maser, of signal strength |
33 | metered at and near the reported, publicly-accessible location in excess of -80 dBm (decibel- |
34 | milliwatt) for any frequency or channel band specified by a transmitting entity's FCC transmission |
| LC004842 - Page 21 of 24 |
1 | license, which entity must comply with all of the following: |
2 | (i) The Federal 1934 Communications Act (CA) requirement at 47 U.S.C. § 324 ch.652, |
3 | Title III, 48 Stat.109 of "minimal amount of power necessary to carry out the communication"; |
4 | (ii) The primary purpose of CA at 47 U.S.C. § 151, as reaffirmed in the 1996 |
5 | Telecommunications Act (TCA) purpose at U.S.C. § 332 (a)(1) Mobile Services: to "promote the |
6 | safety of life and property"; |
7 | (iii) TCA requirements, including the circumscribed preemptions at 47 U.S.C. § 332 |
8 | (c)(7)(A) and (c)(7)(B)(iv) omitting the "health effects" and "operations" of wireless facilities, so |
9 | as to avert any preemption thereof, and preserving state and local officials' authorities to promote |
10 | health, safety, life and property; while acknowledging the actuality of "the environmental effects" |
11 | of the radiation; stating positively, "Except as provided in this paragraph, nothing in this chapter |
12 | shall limit or affect the authority of a state or local government or instrumentality thereof over |
13 | decisions regarding the placement, construction, and modification of personal wireless service |
14 | facilities"; |
15 | (iv) TCA's preemption bounds, which apply solely to mobile phone calls made outdoors |
16 | and not to Internet data or any other wireless communication, rendering all other communications |
17 | outside the bounds of said preemption; |
18 | (v) TCA's Conference Report at H. R. Rep. No. 104-204, pt. 1, p. 94 (1995), leaving |
19 | regulation of the operations of wireless facilities within state and local authorities and specifically |
20 | citing "safety" as regulatory criterion, while warning that any further attempted preemptions |
21 | "should be terminated"; |
22 | (vi) The U.S. Treasury's 2021 recommendation of Internet data speed of 100 Mbps, both |
23 | upload and download, as standard, so that people can efficiently work and study at home; which |
24 | data speed is not achievable through wireless facilities without exceeding the CA's requirement of |
25 | minimum power to carry out the communication, but which speed is easily achievable through |
26 | fiber-optics to the premises (FTTP); |
27 | (vii) The consistent decisions of the federal D.C. Circuit Court of Appeals in 2019 and |
28 | 2021 declaring the FCC's rulemaking "arbitrary and capricious" and without "reasoned |
29 | explanation" in connection with its further deregulated deployments of wireless facilities, and |
30 | particularly to its exposure guideline as non-protective of health and environment, with no |
31 | guideline now extant for ongoing and new transmission frequencies >6 GHz; and |
32 | (viii) The federal Public Health Service Act Amendment of 1968 states at § 354: "The |
33 | Congress hereby declares that the public health and safety must be protected from the dangers of |
34 | electronic product radiation;" thus, the federal stance is clear, with health effects recognized and |
| LC004842 - Page 22 of 24 |
1 | state authorities established and ongoing; or |
2 | (3) Extreme-low-frequency alternating current (AC) electric fields in excess of 1 volt per |
3 | meter (V/m); or |
4 | (4) Magnetic fields in excess of 1 milliGauss (mG); or |
5 | (5) Transients in the electrical wiring, also called "dirty electricity", which must be filtered |
6 | for safety; or |
7 | (6) Ionizing radiation in excess of 0.02 milliSievert per hour (mSv/h); |
8 | (7) Laser, Li-fi, strobe, or other light with harmful effects; or |
9 | (8) Any vibration, noise, saser, sonic weapon, or other physical agent exceeding other |
10 | official limits, guidelines or standards, such as eCode360, shall trigger: |
11 | (i) OC&I's immediate communication of the requirement of the owner or operator of each |
12 | tower, antenna, other facility or infrastructure deploying excessively energy-demanding and/or |
13 | public-exposing transmissions, or other source of energy or vibration at or near the reported |
14 | location, to produce records of all data collection on the extant operators at one or more sites near |
15 | where excessive xenobiotic electromagnetism and fields, mechanical vibration, or other physical |
16 | agents are or have been detected, and to convey said records to the department with twenty-four |
17 | (24) hours; |
18 | (ii) OC&I's immediate communication of the requirement of the owner of the facility, or |
19 | utility or other service equipment at or near the reported location to provide within one business |
20 | day all data collection records up to that date and time of electrical usage at or near the reported |
21 | location. |
22 | (iii) OC&I's order to cease operations of all antennas on, and other deployments of energy |
23 | or vibration emitted from, the measured structure or facility, other than the operations needed for |
24 | police, fire, emergency services, and aviation safety; and |
25 | (iv) OC&I's evaluation within twenty-four (24) hours of the owner's or operator's |
26 | performance in causing the cessation of all operations except those activities exempted under |
27 | subsection (3). |
28 | (v) OC&I's referral of potential criminal activity to the judiciary for prosecution. |
29 | 23-23.8--23. Administrative rules. |
30 | The director may promulgate rules if necessary to implement the provisions of this chapter. |
31 | SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage. |
======== | |
LC004842 | |
======== | |
| LC004842 - Page 23 of 24 |
EXPLANATION | |
BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL | |
OF | |
A N A C T | |
RELATING TO HEALTH AND SAFETY -- THE CLEAN ATMOSPHERE ACT | |
*** | |
1 | This act would establish regulations to reduce hazardous emissions, provide for a natural |
2 | climate, and increase resiliency by prohibiting the intentional manipulation of the environment, and |
3 | collect application and violation fees into a state trust fund for municipality-level allocation for |
4 | projects that promote the safety of life and property as well as environmental and agricultural |
5 | health. For state security, this chapter provides that an entity or individual seeking to engage in an |
6 | atmospheric activity must meet safety, health, and environmental requirements through a public |
7 | hearing process, pay a fee, and show proof of insurance and bonding in order to procure a license |
8 | from the DEM director for any such activity. |
9 | This act would take effect upon passage. |
======== | |
LC004842 | |
======== | |
| LC004842 - Page 24 of 24 |