2013 -- S 0641 SUBSTITUTE A

=======

LC01653/SUB A

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2013

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO PUBLIC UTILITIES AND CARRIERS - DISTRIBUTED GENERATION

STANDARD CONTRACTS

     Introduced By: Senators Walaska, Miller, Paiva Weed, Ruggerio, and DiPalma

     Date Introduced: March 06, 2013

     Referred To: Senate Environment & Agriculture

(Administration)

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Sections 39-26.2-3, 39-26.2-4, 39-26.2-6, 39-26.2-7, 39-26.2-8 and 39-

1-2

26.2-12 of the General Laws in Chapter 39-26.2 entitled "Distributed Generation Standard

1-3

Contracts" are hereby amended to read as follows:

1-4

     39-26.2-3. Definitions. -- When used in this chapter, the following terms shall have the

1-5

following meanings:

1-6

      (1) "Annual target" means the target for total renewable energy nameplate capacity of

1-7

new distributed generation standard contracts set out in section 39-26.2-3.

1-8

      (2) "Commission" means the Rhode Island public utilities commission.

1-9

      (3) "Board" shall mean the distributed generation standard contract board established

1-10

pursuant to the provisions of chapter 39-26.2-9, or the office of energy resources. Until such time

1-11

as the board is duly constituted, the office of energy resources shall serve as the board with the

1-12

same powers and duties pursuant to this chapter.

1-13

      (4) "Distributed generation contract capacity" means ten percent (10%) of an electric

1-14

distribution company's minimum long-term contract capacity under the long-term contracting

1-15

standard for renewable energy in section 39-26.1-2, inclusive of solar capacity. The distributed

1-16

generation contract capacity shall be reserved for acquisition by the electric distribution company

1-17

through standard contracts pursuant to the provisions of this chapter.

1-18

      (5) "Distributed generation facility" means an electrical generation facility that is a

1-19

newly developed renewable energy resource as defined in section 39-26.1-2, located in the

2-1

electric distribution company's load zone with a nameplate capacity no greater than five

2-2

megawatts (5 MW), using eligible renewable energy resources as defined by section 39-26-5,

2-3

including biogas created as a result of anaerobic digestion, but, specifically excluding all other

2-4

listed eligible biomass fuels, and connected to an electrical power system owned, controlled, or

2-5

operated by the electric distribution company.

2-6

      (6) "Distributed generation project" means a distinct installation of a distributed

2-7

generation facility. An installation will be considered distinct if it is installed in a different

2-8

geographical location and at a different time, or if it involves a different type of renewable energy

2-9

class.

2-10

      (7) "Electric distribution company" means a company defined in subdivision 39-1-2(12),

2-11

supplying standard offer service, last resort service, or any successor service to end-use

2-12

customers, but not including the Block Island Power Company or the Pascoag Utility District.

2-13

      (8) "Large distributed generation project" means a distributed generation project that has

2-14

a nameplate capacity that exceeds the size of a small distributed generation project in a given

2-15

year, but is no greater than five three megawatts (5 MW) (3 MW) nameplate capacity.

2-16

     (9) "Office" means the Rhode Island office of energy resources.

2-17

      (9)(10) "Program year" means a calendar year beginning January 1 and ending

2-18

December 31.

2-19

      (10)(11) "Renewable energy classes" means categories for different renewable energy

2-20

technologies using eligible renewable energy resources as defined by section 39-26-5. For each

2-21

program year, the board shall determine the renewable energy classes as are reasonably feasible

2-22

for use in meeting distributed generation objectives from renewable energy resources and are

2-23

consistent with the goal of meeting the annual target for the program year. For the program year

2-24

ending December 31, 2012, there shall be at least four (4) technology classes and at least two (2)

2-25

shall be for solar generation technology, and at least one shall be for wind. The board may add,

2-26

eliminate, or adjust renewable energy classes for each program year with public notice given at

2-27

least sixty (60) days previous to any renewable energy class change becoming effective. For each

2-28

program year, the board shall set renewable energy class targets for each class established. Class

2-29

targets are the total program-year target amounts of nameplate capacity reserved for standard

2-30

contracts for each renewable energy class. The sum of all the class targets shall equal the annual

2-31

target.

2-32

      (11)(12) "Renewable energy credit" means a New England Generation Information

2-33

System renewable energy certificate as defined in subdivision 39-26-2(15);

3-34

      (12)(13) "Small distributed generation project" means a distributed generation renewable

3-35

energy project that has a nameplate capacity no larger than within the following: Solar: fifty

3-36

kilowatts (50 KW) to five hundred kilowatts (500 KW); Wind: fifty kilowatts (50 KW) to one and

3-37

one-half megawatts (1.5 MW). For technologies other than solar and wind, the board shall set the

3-38

nameplate capacity size limits, but such limits may not exceed one megawatt. The board may

3-39

lower the nameplate capacity from year to year for any of these categories, but may not increase

3-40

the capacity beyond what is specified in this definition. In no case may a project developer be

3-41

allowed to segment a distributed generation project into smaller sized projects in order to fall

3-42

under this definition.

3-43

      (13)(14) "Standard contract" means a contract with a term of fifteen (15) years at a fixed

3-44

rate for the purchase of all capacity, energy, and attributes generated by a distributed generation

3-45

facility. A contract may have a different term if it is mutually agreed to by the seller and the

3-46

electric distribution company and it is approved by the commission. The terms of the standard

3-47

contract for each program year and for each renewable energy class shall be set pursuant to the

3-48

provisions of this chapter.

3-49

      (14)(15) "Standard contract ceiling price" means the standard contract price for the

3-50

output of a distributed generation facility which price is approved annually for each renewable

3-51

energy class pursuant to the procedure established in this chapter, for the purchase of energy,

3-52

capacity, renewable energy certificates, and all other environmental attributes and market

3-53

products that are available or may become available from the distributed generation facility.

3-54

     39-26.2-4. Standard contracts -- Annual targets. -- (a) To the extent eligible projects

3-55

are available and submit conforming applications, an electric distribution company shall enter

3-56

into standard contracts for an aggregate nameplate capacity of at least forty megawatts (40 MW)

3-57

of distributed generation projects by the end of 2014, unless such schedule is extended by the

3-58

board. The contracting shall be spread over four (4) years, based on the annual targets, aggregated

3-59

to reflect annual targets from prior program years, contained in the following four (4) year phased

3-60

schedule, unless such schedule is adjusted by the board in any given year:

3-61

      (1) By December 30, 2011: a minimum of five megawatts (5 MW) nameplate;

3-62

      (2) By December 30, 2012: a minimum aggregate of twenty megawatts (20 MW)

3-63

nameplate;

3-64

      (3) By December 30, 2013: a minimum aggregate of thirty megawatts (30 MW)

3-65

nameplate;

3-66

      (4) By December 30, 2014: a minimum aggregate of forty megawatts (40 MW)

3-67

nameplate.

4-68

      (b) By October 15, 2011 and each calendar year following until October 15, 2013, the

4-69

board may recommend to the commission that the annual target for the following program year

4-70

be adjusted upward to reflect any shortfalls in meeting the previous program year's annual target

4-71

or to reflect any standard contracts entered into during prior program years that are voided. The

4-72

board may also recommend to the commission that the annual target for the following program

4-73

year be adjusted downward by any amounts that the previous program year's annual targets were

4-74

exceeded by the standard contracts entered into during that program year.

4-75

      (c) The board may, based on market data and other information available to it including

4-76

pricing for standard contracts received during previous program years, recommend a reduction of

4-77

the annual target for the upcoming program year where the board determines that market

4-78

conditions would be likely to produce unfavorably high target pricing for standard contracts

4-79

during that upcoming program year. In considering such issues, the board may take into account

4-80

the reasonableness of current pricing and its impact on all electric distribution customers who will

4-81

be paying for the output for up to twenty (20) years at such prices. The board may also

4-82

recommend and the commission shall authorize an extension of time to achieve the forty

4-83

megawatt (40 MW) target targets, to allow for contracting to occur after 2014, if necessary.

4-84

      (d) The electric distribution company must contract for at least forty megawatts (40

4-85

MW) of nameplate capacity distributed generation projects by the end of 2014, unless such

4-86

schedule is extended by the board. The electric distribution company may not be required to

4-87

contract for more than forty megawatts (40 MW) or the distributed generation contract capacity,

4-88

but may do so voluntarily, subject to commission approval.

4-89

      (e) Each year, the board shall file its recommendations relating to the schedule, along

4-90

with its report and recommendations regarding ceiling prices, for the commission's review and

4-91

approval as specified in subsection 39-26.2-5(b).

4-92

      (f) Nothing in this chapter shall derogate from the statutory authority of the commission

4-93

or the division, including, but not limited to, the authority to protect ratepayers from unreasonable

4-94

rates.

4-95

     39-26.2-6. Standard contract enrollment program. -- (a) Each electric distribution

4-96

company shall conduct at least three (3) standard contract enrollments during each program year;

4-97

however, during 2011 the electric distribution company need only conduct one enrollment. Each

4-98

enrollment shall be open for a two (2) week period during which the electric distribution

4-99

company is required to receive standard short-form applications requesting standard contracts for

4-100

distributed generation energy projects. The short-form applications shall require the applicant to

4-101

provide the project owner's identity and the project's proposed location, nameplate capacity, and

4-102

renewable energy class and allow for additional information relative to the permitting, financial

5-1

feasibility, ability to build, and timing for deployment of the proposed projects. For small

5-2

distributed generation projects, the applicant must submit an affidavit confirming that the project

5-3

is not a segment of a larger project being planned for enlargement over time. For large distributed

5-4

generation projects, the short-form application shall also require the applicant to bid a bundled

5-5

price for the sale of the energy, capacity, renewable energy certificates, and all other

5-6

environmental attributes and market products that are available or may become available from the

5-7

distributed generation facility, on a per kilowatt-hour basis for the output of the project. Subject

5-8

to the provisions of subsections (b) and (c) below, the electric distribution company shall not be

5-9

required to enter into standard contracts in excess of the annual target for the applicable program

5-10

year and shall not be required to enter into standard contracts in excess of any limit set by the

5-11

board and approved by the commission for a given enrollment. However, the electric distribution

5-12

company may voluntarily exceed an enrollment period limit as long as it does not exceed an

5-13

annual target for the applicable program year.

5-14

      (b) For small distributed generation projects, the electric distribution company on a first-

5-15

come, first-served basis, shall enter into standard contracts at the applicable standard contract

5-16

ceiling price shall select projects for standard contracts based on the lowest proposal prices

5-17

received with any distributed generation project which meets the requirements of all applicable

5-18

tariffs and regulations, and meets the criteria of a renewable energy class in effect, until the class

5-19

target is met. Enrollment periods will be governed by a solicitation and enrollment process rules

5-20

that shall be filed with the commission each October 15 by the electric distribution company, and

5-21

approved by the commission within sixty (60) days of such filing.

5-22

      (c) For large distributed generation projects, the electric distribution company shall

5-23

select projects for standard contracts based on the lowest proposed prices received, but not to

5-24

exceed the applicable standard contract ceiling price, provided, that the selected projects meet the

5-25

requirements of all applicable tariffs and regulations and meet the criteria of a renewable energy

5-26

class in effect until the class target is met. Except for 2011, no enrollment period shall seek to

5-27

enroll more than one-third (1/3) of the annual goal for the distribution company for large

5-28

distributed generation projects.

5-29

      (d) If there are more projects than what is specified for a class target at the same price,

5-30

the electric distribution company shall review the applications submitted and select first those

5-31

projects that appear to be the furthest along in development and likely to be deployed in

5-32

consultation with the office. Those projects that are likely to be deployed on the earliest timelines

5-33

shall be selected. To the extent the electric distribution company is unable to make a clear

5-34

distinction on this basis, the electric company shall report the results to the board and not enter

6-1

into contracts with those projects that are tied on pricing. In such case, the board may take such

6-2

action as it deems appropriate for the selection of projects, including seeking more information

6-3

from the projects. Alternatively, the board may consider adjustments to the ceiling price and a

6-4

rebid, or simply wait until the next enrollment.

6-5

     (e) Should an electric distribution company determine that it has entered into sufficient

6-6

standard contracts to achieve a program-year class target, it shall immediately report this to the

6-7

board, the office of energy resources, and the commission, and cease entering into standard

6-8

contracts for that renewable energy class for the remainder of the program year. An electric

6-9

distribution company may exceed the renewable energy class target if the last standard contract

6-10

entered into may cause the total purchased to exceed the target. The office and the electric

6-11

distribution company shall enter into a memorandum of understanding regarding the sharing of

6-12

the information and data related to the distributed generation program.

6-13

      (f) The electric distribution company is authorized to enter into standard contracts up to

6-14

the applicable ceiling price. As long as the terms of the standard contract are materially the same

6-15

as the standard contract terms approved by the commission and the pricing is no higher than the

6-16

applicable ceiling price, such contracts shall be deemed prudent and approved by the commission

6-17

for purposes of recovering the costs in rates.

6-18

      (g) A distributed generation project that also is being employed by a customer for net

6-19

metering purposes may submit an application to sell the excess output from its distributed

6-20

generation project. In such case, however, at the election of the self-generator all of the renewable

6-21

energy certificates and environmental attributes pertaining to the energy consumed on site may be

6-22

sold to the electric distribution company on a month-to-month basis outside of the terms of the

6-23

standard contract. In such case, the portion of the renewable energy certificates that pertain to the

6-24

energy consumed on site during the net metering billing period shall be priced at the average

6-25

market price of renewable energy certificates, which may be determined by using the price of

6-26

renewable energy certificates purchased or sold by the electric distribution company.

6-27

     39-26.2-7. Standard contract -- Form and provisions. -- The following process shall be

6-28

implemented to establish the non-price terms and conditions of the standard contract:

6-29

      (1) A working group ("contract working group") shall be established and supervised by

6-30

the board, consisting of the following members: (i) The director of the office of energy resources;

6-31

(ii) A designee from the division of public utilities and carriers; (iii) Two (2) designees of the

6-32

electric distribution company; (iv) Two (2) individuals designated by the office of energy

6-33

resources who are experienced developers of renewable generation projects; (v) One individual

6-34

designated by the office of energy resources who represents a customer of the electric distribution

7-1

company; and (vi) A lawyer designated by the office of energy resources who has at least three

7-2

(3) years of experience in negotiating and/or developing power purchase agreements. With

7-3

respect to the lawyer designated in (vi) above, the electric distribution company shall enter into a

7-4

cost reimbursement agreement with such lawyer, to compensate the lawyer for the time spent

7-5

serving in the contract working group at the reasonable hourly rate negotiated by the office of

7-6

energy resources. The costs incurred by the electric distribution company under the

7-7

reimbursement agreement shall be recovered in rates by the electric distribution company in the

7-8

year incurred or the year following incurrence through an appropriate filing with the commission.

7-9

The contract working group shall be an advisory group that is not to be considered to be an

7-10

agency for purposes of the administrative procedures act or any other laws pertaining to public

7-11

bodies.

7-12

      (2) The contract working group shall work in good faith to develop standard contracts

7-13

that would be applicable for various technologies for both small and large distributed generation

7-14

projects. The standard contracts should balance the need for the project to obtain financing

7-15

against the need for the distribution company to protect itself and its distribution customers

7-16

against unreasonable risks. The standard contract should be developed from contracting terms

7-17

typically utilized in the wholesale power industry, taking into account the size of each project and

7-18

the technology. The standard contracts shall provide for the purchase of energy, capacity,

7-19

renewable energy certificates, and all other environmental attributes and market products that are

7-20

available or may become available from the distributed generation facility. However, the electric

7-21

distribution company shall retain the right to separate out pricing for each market product under

7-22

the contracts for administrative and accounting purposes to avoid any detrimental accounting

7-23

effects or for administrative convenience, provided that such accounting as specified in the

7-24

contract does not affect the price and financial benefits to the seller as a seller of a bundled

7-25

product. The standard contract also shall:

7-26

      (i) Hold the distributed generation facility owner liable for the cost of interconnection

7-27

from the distributed generation facility to the interconnect point with the distribution system, and

7-28

for any upgrades to the existing distributed generation system that may be required by the electric

7-29

distribution company. However, a distributed generation facility owner may appeal to the

7-30

commission to reduce any required system upgrade costs to the extent such upgrades can be

7-31

shown to benefit other customers of the electric distribution company and the balance of such

7-32

costs shall be included in rates by the electric distribution company for recovery in the year

7-33

incurred or the year following incurrence;

8-34

      (ii) Require the distributed generation facility owner to make a performance guarantee

8-35

deposit to the electric distribution company of fifteen dollars ($15.00) for small distributed

8-36

generation projects or twenty-five dollars ($25.00) for large distributed generation projects for

8-37

every renewable energy certificate estimated to be generated per year under the contract, but at

8-38

least five hundred dollars ($500) and not more than seventy-five thousand dollars ($75,000), paid

8-39

at the time of contract execution;

8-40

      (iii) Require the electric distribution company to refund the performance guarantee

8-41

deposit on a pro-rated basis of renewable energy credits actually delivered by the distributed

8-42

generation facility over the course of the first year of the project's operation, paid quarterly;

8-43

      (iv) Provide that if the distributed generation facility has not generated ninety percent

8-44

(90%) of the output proposed in its enrollment application within eighteen (18) months after

8-45

execution of the contract, the contract is automatically voided shall be terminated and the

8-46

performance guarantee is shall be forfeited. An eligible small-scale hydropower distributed

8-47

generation facility that has not generated ninety percent (90%) of the output proposed in its

8-48

enrollment application within thirty-six (36) months after execution of the contract shall result in

8-49

the contract being terminated and the performance guarantee being forfeited. Any forfeited

8-50

performance guarantee deposits shall be credited to all distribution customers in rates and not

8-51

retained by the electric distribution company;

8-52

     (v) Provide for flexible payment schedules that may be negotiated between the buyer and

8-53

seller, but shall be no longer than quarterly if an agreement cannot be reached;

8-54

      (vi) Require that an electric meter which conforms with standard industry norms be

8-55

installed to measure the electrical energy output of the distributed generation facility, and require

8-56

a system or procedure by which the distributed generation facility owner shall demonstrate

8-57

creation of renewable energy credits, in a manner recognized and accounted for by the GIS; such

8-58

demonstration of renewable energy credit creation to be at the distributed generation facility

8-59

owner's expense. The electric distribution company may, at its discretion, offer to provide such a

8-60

renewable energy credit measurement and accounting system or procedure to the distributed

8-61

generation facility owner, and the distributed generation facility owner may, at its discretion, use

8-62

the electric distribution company's program, or use that of an independent third party, approved

8-63

by the commission, and the costs of such measurement and accounting are paid for by the

8-64

distributed generation facility owner.

8-65

     (vii) All distributed generation projects that have executed contracts will be required to

8-66

submit quarterly reports on the progress of the project to the distribution company and the office

8-67

of energy resources. Failure to submit these quarterly progress reports may result in the

8-68

termination of the contract.

9-1

      (3) If the contract working group reaches agreement on the terms of standard contracts,

9-2

the board shall file the contracts with the commission for approval. If there are any

9-3

disagreements, they shall be identified to the commission. The commission shall review the

9-4

standard contracts for conformance with the standards set forth in subsection (2). Should there be

9-5

any disputes, the commission shall issue an order resolving them. To the extent the commission

9-6

needs expert assistance to resolve any disagreements noted in the filing, the commission is

9-7

authorized to hire a consultant to assist it in the proceedings, the costs of which shall be recovered

9-8

from electric distribution customers pursuant to a uniform factor established by the commission

9-9

in rates for recovery by the electric distribution company in the year incurred or the year

9-10

following incurrence, as requested through a filing by the electric distribution company. The

9-11

commission shall issue an order approving standard forms of contract within sixty (60) days of

9-12

the filing.

9-13

     39-26.2-8. Standard contract -- Reporting. -- (a) After each enrollment during a

9-14

program year the electric distribution companies shall provide a report to the board, office of

9-15

energy resources, and the commission of the aggregate amount of project nameplate capacity that

9-16

was the subject of standard contracts entered into during that enrollment and the prices under

9-17

each of the standard contracts that were executed.

9-18

      (b) Each quarter of a program year, the electric distribution company shall provide an

9-19

accounting to office of energy resource, the board, and the commission of the total amount paid to

9-20

distributed generation facilities under standard contracts during that quarter, until the forty

9-21

megawatt (40 MW) target is met;

9-22

      (c) Until the forty megawatt (40 MW) target is met, the electric distribution company

9-23

shall submit preliminary reports to office of energy resources, the board, and the commission

9-24

indicating the number of standard contracts and total estimated annual generation, price, class,

9-25

and any other relevant information for the purposes of better specifying classes, targets, or

9-26

standard contract prices so as to achieve the purposes set forth in this chapter. Such reports shall

9-27

be submitted no later than sixty (60) days prior to the end of the calendar year.

9-28

     (d) The electric distribution company shall in consultation with the office utilize uniform

9-29

standard forms for evaluating project proposals and shall rank projects according to uniform

9-30

criteria.

9-31

     (e) At the end of each enrollment, the electric distribution company shall, upon request by

9-32

an applicant, provide said applicant with written feedback on the evaluation of said applicant's

9-33

project proposal.

10-34

     39-26.2-12. Powers and duties. -- The board shall have the power to:

10-35

      (1) Develop and recommend to the public utilities commission for review and approval

10-36

ceiling prices for standard contracts under the distributed generation standard contracts;

10-37

      (2) Develop and recommend to the commission adjustments up or down to the annual

10-38

target for standard contracts for the following program year;

10-39

      (3) Monitor and evaluate performance under the distributed generation standard

10-40

contracts act, including an assessment of ratepayer impact and the project selection process, to be

10-41

submitted annually in a report to the governor and the general assembly.

10-42

      (4) Participate in proceedings of the public utilities commission that pertain to the

10-43

purposes of the board.

10-44

      (5) In order to provide funding for the purposes of engaging consultants and professional

10-45

services as necessary and appropriate for the board to fulfill its duties and purposes, an allocation

10-46

of no less than fifty thousand dollars ($50,000) from unused portions of Regional Greenhouse

10-47

Gas Initiative ("RGGI") auction proceeds not dedicated to efficiency measures but to overhead

10-48

expenses shall be transmitted from the office of energy resources to the board.

10-49

     SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01653/SUB A

========

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO PUBLIC UTILITIES AND CARRIERS - DISTRIBUTED GENERATION

STANDARD CONTRACTS

***

11-1

     This act would amend the definition of a small distributed generation project, and would

11-2

allow hydroelectric projects to participate in the standard contract enforcement program.

11-3

     This act would take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01653/SUB A

=======