2012 -- S 2548 SUBSTITUTE A

=======

LC01597/SUB A

=======

STATE OF RHODE ISLAND

IN GENERAL ASSEMBLY

JANUARY SESSION, A.D. 2012

____________

A N A C T

RELATING TO WATERS AND NAVIGATION - COASTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT

COUNCIL

     Introduced By: Senators Sosnowski, Felag, DiPalma, Walaska, and McCaffrey

     Date Introduced: February 28, 2012

     Referred To: Senate Environment & Agriculture

It is enacted by the General Assembly as follows:

1-1

     SECTION 1. Section 46-23-6 of the General Laws in Chapter 46-23 entitled "Coastal

1-2

Resources Management Council" is hereby amended to read as follows:

1-3

     46-23-6. Powers and duties -- Rights-of-way. -- In order to properly manage coastal

1-4

resources the council has the following powers and duties:

1-5

      (1) Planning and management.

1-6

      (i) The primary responsibility of the council shall be the continuing planning for and

1-7

management of the resources of the state's coastal region. The council shall be able to make any

1-8

studies of conditions, activities, or problems of the state's coastal region needed to carry out its

1-9

responsibilities.

1-10

      (ii) The resources management process shall include the following basic phases:

1-11

      (A) Identify all of the state's coastal resources, water, submerged land, air space, fin fish,

1-12

shellfish, minerals, physiographic features, and so forth.

1-13

      (B) Evaluate these resources in terms of their quantity, quality, capability for use, and

1-14

other key characteristics.

1-15

      (C) Determine the current and potential uses of each resource.

1-16

      (D) Determine the current and potential problems of each resource.

1-17

      (E) Formulate plans and programs for the management of each resource, identifying

1-18

permitted uses, locations, protection measures, and so forth.

2-19

      (F) Carry out these resources management programs through implementing authority and

2-20

coordination of state, federal, local, and private activities.

2-21

      (G) Formulation of standards where these do not exist, and reevaluation of existing

2-22

standards.

2-23

      (H) To develop comprehensive programs for dredging in tidal waters and related

2-24

beneficial use, disposal, monitoring dewatering and transportation of dredge materials.

2-25

      (I) To accept and administer loans and grants from the federal government and from

2-26

other sources, public or private, for the carrying out of any of its functions, which loans or grants

2-27

shall not be expended for other than the purposes for which provided.

2-28

      (J) To encourage, participate in, or conduct studies, investigations, research, and

2-29

demonstrations relating to dredging, disposal of dredge materials and transportation thereof in the

2-30

tidal waters of the state as the coastal resources management council may deem advisable and

2-31

necessary for the discharge of its duties under this chapter.

2-32

      (K) To collect and disseminate information relating to dredging, disposal of dredge

2-33

materials and transportation thereof within the tidal waters of the state.

2-34

      (L) To work with the appropriate federal and state agencies to develop as provided for in

2-35

this chapter and in chapter 6.1 of this title, a comprehensive plan for dredging in tidal waters and

2-36

related beneficial use, disposal, monitoring dewatering and transportation of dredge materials.

2-37

      (M) To apply for, accept and expend grants and bequests of funds, for the purpose of

2-38

carrying out the lawful responsibilities of the coastal resources management council.

2-39

      (iii) An initial series of resources management activities shall be initiated through this

2-40

basic process, then each phase shall continuously be recycled and used to modify the council's

2-41

resources management programs and keep them current.

2-42

      (iv) Planning and management programs shall be formulated in terms of the

2-43

characteristics and needs of each resource or group of related resources. However, all plans and

2-44

programs shall be developed around basic standards and criteria, including:

2-45

      (A) The need and demand for various activities and their impact upon ecological

2-46

systems.

2-47

      (B) The degree of compatibility of various activities.

2-48

      (C) The capability of coastal resources to support various activities.

2-49

      (D) Water quality standards set by the director of the department of environmental

2-50

management.

2-51

      (E) Consideration of plans, studies, surveys, inventories, and so forth prepared by other

2-52

public and private sources.

3-53

      (F) Consideration of contiguous land uses and transportation facilities.

3-54

      (G) Whenever possible consistency with the state guide plan.

3-55

      (v) The council shall prepare, adopt, administer, and cause to be implemented, including

3-56

specifically through its powers of coordination as set forth in subdivision (3) of this section, a

3-57

marine resources development plan and such special area management plans as the council may

3-58

determine to be appropriate or desirable as follows:

3-59

      (A) Marine resources development plan.

3-60

      (I) The purpose of the marine resources development plan shall be to provide an

3-61

integrated strategy for: (a) improving the health and functionality of Rhode Island's marine

3-62

ecosystem; (b) providing for appropriate marine-related economic development; and (c)

3-63

promoting the use and enjoyment of Rhode Island's marine resources by the people of the state.

3-64

      (II) The marine resources development plan shall include specific goals and objectives

3-65

necessary to accomplish its purposes, performance measures to determine progress toward

3-66

achieving such goals and objectives, and an implementation program.

3-67

      (III) The marine resources development plan shall be prepared in cooperation with the

3-68

department of environmental management, the statewide planning program, and the economic

3-69

development corporation, with the involvement of such other state agencies as may be

3-70

appropriate, and with such technical support as may be necessary and appropriate from the

3-71

Narragansett Bay Estuary Program, the Coastal Institute at the University of Rhode Island, and

3-72

Rhode Island Sea Grant.

3-73

      (IV) The plan shall be responsive to the requirements and principles of the federal

3-74

coastal zone management act as amended, including, but not limited to, the expectations of the act

3-75

for incorporating the federal Clean Water Act into coastal zone management programs.

3-76

      (V) The marine resources development plan shall take into account local land use

3-77

management responsibilities as provided for under title 45 and harbor management

3-78

responsibilities, and the preparation of the plan shall include opportunities for involvement and/or

3-79

comment by cities and towns.

3-80

      (VI) The marine resources development plan shall be adopted by the council in

3-81

accordance with the provisions of this subsection by July 1, 2005, shall as appropriate incorporate

3-82

the recommendations of the Governor's Narragansett Bay and Watershed Planning Commission,

3-83

and shall be made consistent with systems level plans as appropriate, in order to effectuate the

3-84

purposes of systems level planning. The council shall update the marine resources development

3-85

plan at least once every five (5) years.

3-86

      (VII) The council shall administer its programs, regulations, and implementation

3-87

activities in a manner consistent with the marine resources development plan.

4-1

      (VIII) The marine resources development plan and any updates thereto shall be adopted

4-2

as appropriate as elements of the state guide plan pursuant to section 42-11-10.

4-3

      (B) Special area management plans.

4-4

      (I) The council shall adopt such special area management plans as deemed necessary and

4-5

desirable to provide for the integration and coordination of the protection of natural resources, the

4-6

promotion of reasonable coastal-dependent economic growth, and the improved protection of life

4-7

and property in the specific areas designated council as requiring such integrated planning and

4-8

coordination.

4-9

      (II) The integrated planning and coordination herein specified shall include, but not be

4-10

limited to, federal agencies, state agencies, boards, commissions, and corporations, including

4-11

specifically the economic development corporation, and cities and towns, shall utilize to the

4-12

extent appropriate and feasible the capacities of entities of higher education, including Rhode

4-13

Island Sea Grant, and shall provide for the participation of advocacy groups, community-based

4-14

organizations, and private persons.

4-15

      (III) The council shall administer its programs, regulations, and implementation

4-16

activities in a manner consistent with special area management plans.

4-17

      (IV) Special area management plans and any updates thereto shall be adopted as

4-18

appropriate as elements of the state guide plan pursuant to section 42-11-10.

4-19

      (2) Implementation.

4-20

      (i) The council is authorized to formulate policies and plans and to adopt regulations

4-21

necessary to implement its various management programs. With respect to such policies and

4-22

plans which relate to matters where the coastal resources management council and the department

4-23

of environmental management have concurrent jurisdiction and upon formulation of the plans and

4-24

regulations, the council shall, prior to adoption, submit the proposed plans or regulations to the

4-25

director of the department of environmental management for the director's review. The director

4-26

shall review and submit comments to the council within thirty (30) days of submission to the

4-27

director by the council. The comments of the director shall include findings with regard to the

4-28

consistency of the policies, plans and/or regulations with the requirements of laws administered

4-29

by the department. The council shall consider the director's comments prior to adoption of any

4-30

such policies, plans or regulations and shall respond in writing to findings of the director with

4-31

regard to the consistency of said policies, plans and/or regulations with the requirements of laws

4-32

administered by the department.

4-33

      (ii) (A) The council shall have exclusive jurisdiction below mean high water for all

4-34

development, operations, and dredging, consistent with the requirements of chapter 6.1 of this

5-1

title and except as necessary for the department of environmental management to exercise its

5-2

powers and duties and to fulfill its responsibilities pursuant to sections 42-17.1-2 and 42-17.1-24,

5-3

and any person, firm, or governmental agency proposing any development or operation within,

5-4

above, or beneath the tidal water below the mean high water mark, extending out to the extent of

5-5

the state's jurisdiction in the territorial sea, shall be required to demonstrate that its proposal

5-6

would not:

5-7

      (I) Conflict with any resources management plan or program;

5-8

      (II) Make any area unsuitable for any uses or activities to which it is allocated by a

5-9

resources management plan or program adopted by the council; or

5-10

      (III) Significantly damage the environment of the coastal region.

5-11

      (B) The council shall be authorized to approve, modify, set conditions for, or reject any

5-12

such proposal.

5-13

      (iii) The authority of the council over land areas (those areas above the mean high water

5-14

mark) shall be limited to two hundred feet (200') from the coastal physiographic feature or to that

5-15

necessary to carry out effective resources management programs. This shall be limited to the

5-16

authority to approve, modify, set conditions for, or reject the design, location, construction,

5-17

alteration, and operation of specified activities or land uses when these are related to a water area

5-18

under the agency's jurisdiction, regardless of their actual location. The council's authority over

5-19

these land uses and activities shall be limited to situations in which there is a reasonable

5-20

probability of conflict with a plan or program for resources management or damage to the coastal

5-21

environment. These uses and activities are:

5-22

      (A) Power generating over forty (40) megawatts and desalination plants.

5-23

      (B) Chemical or petroleum processing, transfer, or storage.

5-24

      (C) Minerals extraction.

5-25

      (D) Shoreline protection facilities and physiographical features, and all directly

5-26

associated contiguous areas which are necessary to preserve the integrity of the facility and/or

5-27

features.

5-28

      (E) Coastal wetlands and all directly associated contiguous areas which are necessary to

5-29

preserve the integrity of the wetlands including any freshwater wetlands located in the vicinity of

5-30

the coast. The actual determination of freshwater wetlands located in coastal vicinities and under

5-31

the jurisdiction of the coastal resources management council shall be designated on such maps

5-32

that are agreed to in writing and made available for public use by the coastal resources

5-33

management council and the director, department of environmental management, within three (3)

5-34

months of [August 6, 1996]. The CRMC shall have exclusive jurisdiction over the wetlands areas

6-1

described in this section notwithstanding any provision of chapter 1, title 2 or any other provision

6-2

except that the division of agriculture maintains jurisdiction over all farming consistent with

6-3

section 2-1-22(i) and (j), except as provided in subsection (iv) of this section. Within six (6)

6-4

months of [August 6, 1996] the council in cooperation with the director shall develop rules and

6-5

regulations for the management and protection of freshwater wetlands, affected by an aquaculture

6-6

project, outside of those freshwater wetlands located in the vicinity of the coast and under the

6-7

exclusive jurisdiction of the director of the department of environmental management. For the

6-8

purpose of this chapter, a "coastal wetland" means any salt marsh bordering on the tidal waters of

6-9

this state, whether or not the tidal waters reach the littoral areas through natural or artificial

6-10

watercourses, and those uplands directly associated and contiguous thereto which are necessary to

6-11

preserve the integrity of that marsh. Marshes shall include those areas upon which grow one or

6-12

more of the following: smooth cordgrass (spartina alterniflora), salt meadow grass (spartina

6-13

patens), spike grass (distichlis spicata), black rush (juncus gerardi), saltworts (salicornia spp.), sea

6-14

lavender (limonium carolinianum), saltmarsh bulrushes (scirpus spp.), hightide bush (iva

6-15

frutescens), tall reed (phragmites communis), tall cordgrass (spartina pectinata), broadleaf cattail

6-16

(typha latifolia), narrowleaf cattail (typha angustifolia), spike rush (eleocharis rostellata),

6-17

chairmaker's rush (scirpus amercana), creeping bentgrass (agrostis palustris), sweet grass

6-18

(hierochloe odorata), and wild rye (etlymus virginicus).

6-19

      (F) Sewage treatment and disposal and solid waste disposal facilities.

6-20

      (G) Beneficial use, dewatering, and disposal of dredged material of marine origins,

6-21

where such activities take place within two hundred (200) feet of mean high water or a coastal

6-22

physiographic feature, or where there is a reasonable probability of conflict with a plan or

6-23

program for resources management or damage to the coastal environment.

6-24

     (iv) Notwithstanding the provisions of subsections (ii) and (iii) above, the department of

6-25

environmental management shall maintain jurisdiction over the administration of chapter 1, title

6-26

2, including permitting of freshwater wetlands alterations and enforcement, with respect to all

6-27

agricultural activities undertaken by a farmer, as that term is defined in subsection 2-1-22(j),

6-28

wherever located; provided, however, that with respect to activities located partially or

6-29

completely within two hundred feet (200’) of the coastal physiographic feature, the department

6-30

shall exercise jurisdiction in consultation with the council.

6-31

      (3) Coordination. - The council has the following coordinating powers and duties:

6-32

      (i) Functioning as a binding arbitrator in any matter of dispute involving both the

6-33

resources of the state's coastal region and the interests of two (2) or more municipalities or state

6-34

agencies.

7-1

      (ii) Consulting and coordinating actions with local, state, regional, and federal agencies

7-2

and private interests.

7-3

      (iii) Conducting or sponsoring coastal research.

7-4

      (iv) Advising the governor, the general assembly, and the public on coastal matters.

7-5

      (v) Serving as the lead state agency and initial and primary point of contact for dredging

7-6

activities in tidal waters and in that capacity, integrating and coordinating the plans and policies

7-7

of other state agencies as they pertain to dredging in order to develop comprehensive programs

7-8

for dredging as required by subparagraph (1)(ii)(H) of this section and chapter 6.1 of this title.

7-9

The Rhode Island resource recovery corporation prior to purchasing cover material for the state

7-10

landfill shall first contact the CRMC to see if there is a source of suitable dredged material

7-11

available which shall be used in place of the purchase cover material. Other state agencies

7-12

engaged in the process of dump closures shall also contact the CRMC to see if there is a source of

7-13

suitable dredged material available, which shall be used in place of the purchase cover material.

7-14

In addition, cities and towns may contact the CRMC prior to closing city or town controlled

7-15

dump sites to see if there is a source of suitable dredge material available, which may be used in

7-16

place of the purchase cover material.

7-17

      (vi) Acting as the state's representative to all bodies public and private on all coastal and

7-18

aquaculture related matters.

7-19

      (4) Operations. - The council is authorized to exercise the following operating functions,

7-20

which are essential to management of coastal resources:

7-21

      (i) Issue, modify, or deny permits for any work in, above, or beneath the areas under its

7-22

jurisdiction, including conduct of any form of aquaculture.

7-23

      (ii) Issue, modify, or deny permits for dredging, filling, or any other physical alteration

7-24

of coastal wetlands and all directly related contiguous areas which are necessary to preserve the

7-25

integrity of the wetlands, including, but not limited to, the transportation and disposal of dredge

7-26

materials in the tidal waters.

7-27

      (iii) Grant licenses, permits, and easements for the use of coastal resources which are

7-28

held in trust by the state for all its citizens, and impose fees for private use of these resources.

7-29

      (iv) Determining the need for and establishing pierhead, bulkhead, and harbor lines.

7-30

      (v) Enforcing and implementing riparian rights in the tidal waters after judicial decisions.

7-31

      (vi) The council may require an owner or operator of a commercial wharf or pier of a

7-32

marine commercial facility, as defined in 300.3 of the Rhode Island coastal resources

7-33

management program, but not including those facilities defined in 300.4 of the Rhode Island

7-34

coastal resources management program, and which is capable of offloading cargo, and is or will

8-1

be subject to a new use or a significant intensification of an existing use, to demonstrate that the

8-2

commercial wharf or pier is fit for that purpose. For the purposes of this subsection, a

8-3

"commercial wharf or pier" means a pier, bulkhead, wharf, docking facility, or underwater

8-4

utilities. The council may order said owner or operator to provide an engineering certification to

8-5

the council's satisfaction that the commercial wharf or pier is fit for the new use or intensification

8-6

of an existing use. If the council determines that the commercial wharf or pier is not fit, it may

8-7

order the owner or operator to undertake the necessary work to make the commercial wharf or

8-8

pier safe, within a reasonable time frame. If the council determines that the commercial wharf or

8-9

pier, because of is condition, is an immediate threat to public health and safety it may order the

8-10

commercial wharf or pier closed until the necessary work to make the commercial wharf or pier

8-11

safe has been performed and approved by the council. All work performed must conform to the

8-12

council's management program. The council is also given the authority to develop regulations to

8-13

carry out this provision and to impose administrative penalties of five thousand dollars ($5,000)

8-14

per day up to a maximum of twenty thousand dollars ($20,000) consistent with section 46-23-7.1

8-15

where there has been a violation of the orders under this provision.

8-16

      (5) Rights-of-way.

8-17

      (i) The council is responsible for the designation of all public rights-of-way to the tidal

8-18

water areas of the state, and shall carry on a continuing discovery of appropriate public rights-of-

8-19

way to the tidal water areas of the state.

8-20

      (ii) The council shall maintain a complete file of all official documents relating to the

8-21

legal status of all public rights-of-way to the tidal water areas of the state.

8-22

      (iii) (A) The council has the power to designate for acquisition and development, and

8-23

posting, and all other functions of any other department for tidal rights-of-way and land for tidal

8-24

rights-of-way, parking facilities, and other council related purposes.

8-25

      (B) Further, the council has the power to develop and prescribe a standard sign to be

8-26

used by the cities and towns to mark designated rights-of-way.

8-27

      (iv) In conjunction with this subdivision, every state department controlling state-owned

8-28

land close to or adjacent to discovered rights-of-way is authorized to set out the land, or so much

8-29

of the land that may be deemed necessary for public parking.

8-30

      (v) No use of land for public parking shall conflict with existing or intended use of the

8-31

land, and no improvement shall be undertaken by any state agency until detailed plans have been

8-32

submitted to and approved by the governing body of the local municipality.

8-33

      (vi) In designating rights-of-way, the council shall consider the following matters in

8-34

making its designation:

9-1

      (A) Land evidence records;

9-2

      (B) The exercise of domain over the parcel such as maintenance, construction, or

9-3

upkeep;

9-4

      (C) The payment of taxes;

9-5

      (D) The creation of a dedication;

9-6

      (E) Public use;

9-7

      (F) Any other public record or historical evidence such as maps and street indexes;

9-8

      (G) Other evidence as set out in section 42-35-10.

9-9

      (vii) A determination by the council that a parcel is a right-of-way shall be decided by

9-10

substantial evidence.

9-11

      (viii) The council shall be notified whenever by the judgment of the governing body of a

9-12

coastal municipality, a public right-of-way to tidal water areas located in such municipality has

9-13

ceased to be useful to the public, and such governing body proposes an order of abandonment of

9-14

such public right-of-way. Said notice shall be given not less than sixty (60) days prior to the date

9-15

of such abandonment.

9-16

      (6) Pre-existing residential boating facilities.

9-17

      (i) The council is hereby authorized and empowered to issue assent for pre-existing

9-18

residential boating facilities constructed prior to January 1, 1985. These assents may be issued for

9-19

pre-existing residential boating facilities, even though such facilities do not meet current

9-20

standards and policies of the council; provided, however, that the council finds that such facilities

9-21

do not pose any significant risk to the coastal resources of the state of Rhode Island and do not

9-22

endanger human safety.

9-23

      (ii) In addition to the above criteria, the applicant shall provide clear and convincing

9-24

evidence that:

9-25

      (A) The facility existed in substantially the same configuration as it now exists prior to

9-26

January 1, 1985;

9-27

      (B) The facility is presently intact and functional; and

9-28

      (C) The facility presents no significant threat to the coastal resources of the state of

9-29

Rhode Island or human safety.

9-30

      (iii) The applicant, to be eligible for this provision, shall apply no later than January 31,

9-31

1999.

9-32

      (iv) The council is directed to develop rules and regulations necessary to implement this

9-33

subdivision.

10-34

      (v) It is the specific intent of this subsection to require that all pre-existing residential

10-35

boating facilities constructed on January 1, 1985 or thereafter conform to this chapter and the

10-36

plans, rules and regulations of the council.

10-37

      (7) Lease of filled lands which were formerly tidal lands to riparian or littoral owners.

10-38

      (i) Any littoral or riparian owner in this state who desires to obtain a lease from the state

10-39

of Rhode Island of any filled lands adjacent to his or her upland shall apply to the council, which

10-40

may make the lease. Any littoral or riparian owner who wishes to obtain a lease of filled lands

10-41

must obtain pre-approval, in the form of an assent, from the council. Any lease granted by the

10-42

council shall continue the public's interest in the filled lands including, but not limited to, the

10-43

rights of navigation, fishery, and commerce. The public trust in the lands shall continue and run

10-44

concurrently with the leasing of the lands by the state to private individuals, corporations, or

10-45

municipalities. Upon the granting of a lease by the council, those rights consistent with the public

10-46

trust and secured by the lease shall vest in the lessee. The council may approve a lease of filled

10-47

lands for an initial term of up to fifty (50) years, with, or without, a single option to renew for an

10-48

additional term of up to fifty (50) years.

10-49

      (ii) The lessor of the lease, at any time, for cause, may by express act cancel and annul

10-50

any lease previously made to the riparian owner when it determines that the use of the lands is

10-51

violating the terms of the lease or is inconsistent with the public trust, and upon cancellation the

10-52

lands, and rights in the land so leased, shall revert to the state.

10-53

      (8) "Marinas" as defined in the coastal resources management program in effect as of

10-54

June 1, 1997, are deemed to be one of the uses consistent with the public trust. Subdivision (7) is

10-55

not applicable to:

10-56

      (i) Any riparian owner on tidal waters in this state (and any successor in interest to the

10-57

owner) which has an assent issued by the council to use any land under water in front of his or her

10-58

lands as a marina, which assent was in effect on June 1, 1997;

10-59

      (ii) Any alteration, expansion, or other activity at a marina (and any successor in interest)

10-60

which has an assent issued by the council, which assent was in effect on June 1, 1997; and

10-61

      (iii) Any renewal of assent to a marina (or successor in interest), which assent was issued

10-62

by the council and in effect on June 1, 1997.

10-63

      (9) "Recreational boating facilities" including marinas, launching ramps, and recreational

10-64

mooring areas, as defined by and properly permitted by the council, are deemed to be one of the

10-65

uses consistent with the public trust. Subdivision (7) is not applicable to:

10-66

      (i) Any riparian owner on tidal waters in this state (and any successor in interest to the

10-67

owner) which has an assent issued by the council to use any land under water in front of his or her

10-68

lands as a recreational boating facility; any alteration, expansion or other activity at a recreational

11-1

boating facility (and any successor in interest) which has an assent issued by the council, which

11-2

assent was in effect as of June 1, 1997; and

11-3

      (ii) Any renewal of assent to a recreational boating facility (or successor in interest),

11-4

which assent was issued by the council and in effect on June 1, 1997.

11-5

     SECTION 2. This act shall take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01597/SUB A

========

EXPLANATION

BY THE LEGISLATIVE COUNCIL

OF

A N A C T

RELATING TO WATERS AND NAVIGATION - COASTAL RESOURCES MANAGEMENT

COUNCIL

***

12-1

     This act would provide that agricultural wetlands in the state’s coastal regions that are

12-2

used by a farmer for normal farming activities would be subject to the exclusive jurisdiction and

12-3

enforcement of the department of environmental management, except, with respect to activities

12-4

located partially or completely within two hundred feet (200’) of the coastal physiographic

12-5

feature, the department of environmental management would exercise jurisdiction in consultation

12-6

with the council.

12-7

     This act would take effect upon passage.

=======

LC01597/SUB A

=======